The only reasoning I can see to not take Kelly is if the Bills have an Ace up there sleeve and either believe that some other WR is worth the #11 pick, or they take a CB/DE and then trade back up into the late 1st or early 2nd and grab a WR they have targeted like they did with Poz and McCargo in the last 2 drafts.

I will admit.  Seeing Kelly in a Bills uniform, making plays, really gets my juices flowing.

Analysis

Positives: Has a solid build with good upper-body muscle definition, long arms and legs, big thighs and calves, good bubble, tight skin and room to carry at least another 10 pounds of bulk without having the additional weight impact his foot speed...Big-time playmaker who is a threat to score every time he touches the ball and must be accounted for at all times...Tough receiver who isn't afraid to take a hit...Has very large, natural hands with decent deep speed (more quick than fast), as his long legs and running stride let him consistently eat up the cushion and get behind the defensive back...Has the outstanding ability to change direction in an instant, doing a good job of adjusting his body to off-target tosses...Combines good strength and burst to beat the jam and elude tacklers...Displays the natural ability to catch with his hands extended outside the frame...Aggressive cut blocker who won't back down and thrives when he gets the ball in pressure situations...Fights for the ball along the sideline, keeping his feet inbounds...Has super quickness off the snap and into his routes, showing good precision in his breaks...Might lack explosion, but he comes off the line with good power and finesse, as he stays under control through his patterns, running sharp, crisp routes and using his strength and size to bust through the jam...Can gain ground and separate in space...Shows no wasted movement, as he is effective at dropping his weight getting into his patterns, which is surprising to see as most tall receivers don't have the fluid hips or elusiveness that Kelly displays...Does a good job of reading coverage and adjusting in his routes, especially when working underneath...Has the ability to pull away from second-level defenders after the catch, using his strength to break arm tackles...Alert to pocket pressure, showing urgency working back to the ball...Solid short-area receiver that gets his head around quickly to locate the ball, remaining focused going for the ball in a crowd, as he knows how to use his frame to shield defenders...Plucks and secures the ball with ease and can take a hit and hold on to the ball working through traffic (knows how to use his height and long arms to his advantage)...Lacks suddenness in his initial step, but he has the quickness to separate, can fade into the open area and easily track the ball in flight...Even though he is a big target, he can bend, reach and jump for the ball while staying in control and maintaining his stride (has better ability to adjust in his intermediate and deep routes than in the short area)...Finds the ball in flight quickly and has the flexibility to adjust to it in the air...With his long arms and explosive leaping, he will win most jump balls...Shows elusiveness and strength after the catch, as he can either make the first defender miss or run through arm tackles...Good position blocker to seal off and shows proper hand placement to sustain blocks.

Negatives: Lacks the short steps and quick feet, but does get good depth in his route progression with his long stride...Perhaps a product of the team's reliance on its ground game, he will disappear for long stretches...A good blocker, he is basically a non-factor without the ball in his hands...Will usually run crisp routes but he will glide out of his breaks, possibly because of the hip pointer he suffered vs. Oklahoma State...Keeps his head on a swivel to locate the ball, but is more effective as a receiver in the open field, as he does not show the same burst as smaller receivers when catching in the short area...Not really an explosive player, but does use his body lean and initial contact strike to create separation.

Compares To: LARRY FITZGERALD-Arizona...Like Fitzgerald, Kelly takes advantage of his size and strength to break arm tackles rather than trying to get fancy with moves when trying to separate. Both have some of the best natural hands in the game, as Kelly was charted with only one dropped pass in the last two years. Perhaps due to the team's reliance on the running game, he will disappear for stretches on the field. But when he gets into that rhythm he will catch everything in site. Some teams might prefer Indiana's James Hardy, but Kelly is a more natural receiver and comes with no off-field baggage. Could be a perfect fit in Cincinnati with Carson Palmer if Cincinnati trades Chad Johnson.

Injury Report

2006. Suffered a slight concussion vs. Texas A&M (11/04)...Left the Fiesta Bowl (1/01/07) in the first quarter with cartilage damage in his knee, undergoing surgery that kept him sidelined for 2007 spring camp.
2007. Suffered a hip pointer on the first series of the Oklahoma State clash (11/24) and saw just a few snaps in that contest...Suffered a leg contusion early in the first quarter vs. West Virginia (1/02/08) in the Fiesta Bowl and did not return to the game.

I've also stated that great wide receivers must be able to catch.  Kelly catches everything in site.  He attacks the ball in the air.  Outstanding catching radius.  Kelly can be open without getting separation.

Along with Lee Evans, I think the Bills would have one of, if not the, best tandem of "catching" wide receivers in the league.  Both Evans and Kelly possess tremendous hand strength.

Kelly is not in the elite class of Calvin Johnson (taken #2 overall in 2007), Roy Williams (#7 in 2004), and Andre Johnson (#3 in 2003).  I actually think that Kelly is more comparable to Larry Fitzgerald (#3 in 2004) than Anquan Boldin (ironically they play for the same team).  Either way, it's a great complement.  While Kelly lacks Fitzgerald's polish and production coming into the NFL, they are similar in competing for and catching the ball in traffic.  Kelly may be a little faster than Fitzgerald and Boldin.  Boldin is a tremendous YAC receiver; I don't think that Kelly is as good as Boldin after the catch.

Go Bills!

Actually the more I research this dang draft and the #11 pick, the more flustered I get!  I just love taking a WR.  Which one, I'm not so sure yet.

If I had to find a comparison for Kelly I think I'd go with Plaxico. Both are good hands catchers, go up and get it, and seem to enjoy the stiff arm.  Maybe a poor man's Larry Fitz is a good comparison as well.

Is it just me, or does Limas Sweed seem so much faster than Kelly? I really am starting to like Sweed all over again.  I'm bumping Thomas back to 3rd with Sweed/Kelly fighting for my poll position.

Malcolm Kelly is the player I voted for in the poll so I'm not going to disagree with your selection there, Brian.  

With that said, it seems to me that Devin Thomas would work better with Edwards, based on his scouting reports.

Should Edwards talents (or lack of) be considered when they pick a WR?

Edwards has a 100 miles to go to be anything in this league.  But just running Lynch and punting the ball and lacking scoring is something I can't continue to see!  Gotta just keep adding talent and hope that Edwards matures faster and more efficiently than JP ever did

So basically, slow, can't jump, but is kinda quick