Five Keys to Trent Edwards' 2008 Progression
It's the well-known, yet rarely discussed (here, anyways) secret key to success for the 2008 Buffalo Bills - even with all of the positive additions this team has made heading into the '08 season, it's highly unlikely that the team challenges for a playoff berth unless the team gets better, more consistent quarterback play.
That pressure falls squarely on the shoulders, of course, of second-year starting quarterback Trent Edwards. Despite leading a statistically mediocre (okay, downright awful) offense last season, Edwards did show flashes of being able to efficiently lead an NFL offense, and doing it consistently in the near future. But he's not there yet. He'll need help in five key areas in order to pull it off; without hitting on a majority of these areas, the Bills' chances at a 2008 playoff berth remain bleak.
Key One: Improved Play Calling
We've discussed this key ad nauseum several times throughout the off-season: Buffalo has some tools to work with offensively; they just need to utilize them in the correct fashion. Last season, Edwards' offenses were held back because of his inexperience; as a result, Buffalo's offenses were incredibly vanilla, very basic in nature, not creative, and ultimately very easy to defend. Edwards-led offenses didn't score enough points in 2007, and that's the basic truth that needs to change this season. New offensive coordinator Turk Schonert can help Edwards achieve that by creatively using the talents of his multi-dimensional offensive players (namely, RB Marshawn Lynch) and keeping defenses off balance with the play-action, rollouts, or whatever works.
Key Two: Risk Taking
Along the same thought process, Buffalo's offensive mindset needs to be much more aggressive in 2008 than it was in 2007. Clearly, that mindset needs to be inherited by the coaching staff in their game-day scheming (see above), but it also applies directly to Edwards as well. Not since high school has Edwards been given free reign to take chances; in his years at Stanford and as a Bills rookie, he's been conditioned to minimize mistakes on terrible offensive football teams. Minimizing mistakes is fine, but it needs to happen without the training wheels. Edwards has the accuracy and quick release to make the tight throws; he can't make them, however, if he doesn't attempt them. Trent needs to take more risks; if he does and they pay off, it'll help the team win games as well as build toward Key Three.
Key Three: Becoming a Leader
Bills coaches and teammates have been singing Edwards' praises all off-season - which isn't a bad thing - but this is the NFL. The off-season is as much about good PR as it is about improving your team's roster. Saying that you're confident in Edwards is much different than believing in him. Edwards has already proven to be a good locker room guy with an outstanding work ethic; he studies hard and has scheduled throwing sessions outside of normal practice settings with two of his top targets in Lee Evans and Robert Royal. That's leadership. But respect is also a big part of leadership, and right now, not many opponents respect Edwards' game. Proving it on the field will be the biggest step Edwards can take in assuming a full leadership role for a franchise that hasn't had a leader at this position since the starter wore #12.
Key Four: Getting Experience
There's also the idea that each of the three above keys can be achieved simply by playing, and playing a lot. "Getting experience" is an easy heading to throw the rest of these keys under, but I'm not talking in generalities here - we'll keep the off-field experiences out of this equation. I'm talking specifically about becoming intricately familiar with the team's playbook, the strengths and weaknesses of his offensive teammates, and building chemistry with the team's offensive coaching staff. If Edwards feels that the coaches aren't playing to his strengths, he needs to tell them that. Edwards can't be spoon-fed, because let's face it - parenting ain't easy, and neither is coaching. The general feeling is that Edwards already plays an active role in his own practice and study rituals, which is great; he'll need to continue working with, not for, his bosses if he's to gain that familiarity he desperately needs.
Key Five: The Media
Ultimately, we need to realize that we're talking about a kid that's athletically gifted and very intelligent, but needs to take his lumps. You don't grow as an NFL quarterback unless you make mistakes, and Edwards will make his fair share in 2008. Complicating that issue, however, is a certain former first-round pick currently backing up Edwards. If Trent falters - which is likely going to happen; it just depends on how his peaks relate to his valleys in terms of length - you can bet the "what if J.P. Losman started instead?" thought process will resurface via the Buffalo media. It's an ugly thought to be sure, but this city's big media corporations seem to thrive on covering quarterback controversies, even if they have to create them themselves. Enter the 2008 season as a fan of this team ready to repeat this mantra during the tough times:
Trent will learn from this. He needs this experience. Just because some big media pundit says Losman should start doesn't mean he's right. In fact, he's dead wrong - he's just trying to sell papers. No, I WON'T listen to the man - Edwards has the ability to overcome this. Trust the kid. Don't trust controversy.
(We'll repeat this throughout the season in case you forget some of the words.)
There you have it - five key areas where Trent Edwards needs to make significant strides during or, ideally, before the 2008 season. Feel free to discuss/embellish the ideas, as well as vote in/break down the below poll, in the comments section.
1 recs |
33 comments
Comments
How about
Lee Evans actually playing like a #1 WR? I know he shouldn’t be one, but he is one here. Time for him to play like it and be more than a deep threat.
~K
by Kurupt on Jul 9, 2008 8:36 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
More Worried About Teammates Than Media
I’m less worried about how the media reacts than I am about the teammates. They know they can win this year. If they think Trent is holding them back, they’ll turn on him. Being nice and saying the right things isn’t enough. If he delivers in the clutch (like the Washington game) then they’ll stay with him longer through tough times.
by MrFurious1 on Jul 9, 2008 8:50 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Lynch and Line
If Lynch gets more touches through the air and this line learns to run block together, that will open up alot. Remember, Lynch was still a rookie last year, and even though Adrian Peterson had an unbelievable year, I expect to see pushing the envelope his sophmore year. And with the addition of the FB, I think a powerful run game will make our passing attack that much better, and therefore, allow Edwards, a smart and savvy qb with a quick release, to eat up defenses. What will suck, I guess, would be if Edwards goes down, and all the offensive changes also benefit JP, who then lights it up for few games. Then there will be the dreaded controversy, but oh well, this is the Bills.
This town needs an enema!
by killascript on Jul 9, 2008 9:32 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
That Wouldn't Suck if JP Plays Well...
Having two quarterbacks that can get the job done wouldn’t suck. It’s a safe bet that Trent will miss some time this year. Most QBs do. I feel confident JP can get it done in his 4th year on the best team we’ve had in that time. That may cause some media and fan chatter, but Trent’s evaluation is independent. If he plays well, he plays. If he doesn’t play well for prolonged periods of time, he’ll get pressure from the backup. There are only 32 starting jobs. Only a very few quartebacks can play poorly and not start to feel the heat of the backup. That’s pro sports. I want a backup that can play. If the starter can’t handle the heat from the backup, then he’s not the right man for the job.
by MrFurious1 on Jul 9, 2008 10:00 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I should have said "suck"
I have liked JP in the past, and to me, he “could” be exciting. But if Trent goes down, and JP lights it up, what would suck is the media and fan chatter. I want a clear cut number one, but I want to win above all else, so who cares. If Trent goes down on a season ending injury, and JP leads us into the playoffs, I say we lock him up. Or at least, someone should be thinking about it.
This town needs an enema!
by killascript on Jul 9, 2008 11:16 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
My three keys
Trent staying healthy and playing 16 games.
Experience is the most important thing for Trent. He needs to get better if the Bills are going anywhere and I still think this is a team that could slip into the back end of the playoffs, but doesn’t belong there. A season of being the leader, fully understanding the system and getting a rapport with Hardy is what Trent needs the most.
Improvement from the WRs
Lee Evans needs to get better at running non-straight patterns. The guy looks great trying to get deep, but he needs to become a more consistent player on a variety of routes. If James Hardy isn’t ready to contribute, than this offense will look a lot like last season’s. Trent needs weapons at the ready if he is going to improve to a playoff calibur level.
help from the defense and special teams
A lot of the praise given to Edwards has been based on the fact that he won some games last year. If he is going to be viewed as a leader and if the fans and media embrace him, it will be because the team is winning. The Bills are going to need some Dick Jauron style low scoring, close victories this year to cover up some QB inconsistant performances.
by kaisertown on Jul 9, 2008 9:54 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I think
Its as simple as the Play-Calling, and philosophy of Turk Schonert, combined with Edwards having more confidence because he should be more “sure” of himself being he played a lot last year, and I think naturally he is a confident QB. But jumping to the NFL is a different leap. They have the same O-line. Only additions on offense of signifigance is Hardy. Sprinkle in Andersen and Fine.
All that said, JP Losman had what we all thought was the “right” situation to succeed and he didn’t get it done. And I don’t think all the blame can go on the QB, but Trent needs to really be a playmaker for this team to reach the playoffs cuz they will stack 8-9 guys in the box and I think not having SFM to run a screen play on 3rd and 5 in the red zone should benefit us. We have to use the weapons available and that means aggressive play calling. I’m so glad Fairchild is gone. MAN, what a waste he was
MARVelous
by MARVelous on Jul 9, 2008 9:55 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
MARVelous, simply MARVelous
I’m with you on this one. Play calling is going to be a big factor. Granted, with Trent being a rookie last season, it was probably a good thing to run a dumbed-down offensive scheme to minimize mistakes. But I’m pretty sure that if the Bills’ 2007 offense was pathetically predictable to myself (and thousands of other Bills’ fans), that opposing NFL defenses were able to dissect it and know it better in a week’s time than our team did. That’s why I like Turk’s approach so much – so far it’s been like a breath of fresh air to see someone finally tailor the offense to the QB’s strengths. About time! And putting pre-snap motion back in the blueprints will help Trent with reading defenses at the line of scrimmage. Diversifying the offense will make it that much more difficult to prepare for.
J.P. had a good chance to be starter here, and just couldn’t manage to nail down the job for various reasons. I love the potential he has, but I’m not convinced about his ability to consistently make good decisions. Of course, there was a time when I thought the same applied about Jim Kelly, too… All the same, I’m glad to have J.P. backing up Trent this season. We could be so much worse off.
Get the Bills back to the big game!
by Blitz on Jul 9, 2008 10:18 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Confidence
Why do you think that Edwards is a naturally confident QB? As Brian alluded to, Edwards’ reluctance to take chances indicates his lack of confidence, to some degree.
Will more aggressive play calling make a difference? After the Bills’ defense forced 4 turnovers (the other 2 were returned for touchdowns) versus Dallas on MNF, the Bills offense took possession. Many great opportunities to catch the Dallas defense off-guard with a deep pass or a shot at the end zone, right? Well, those plays were called. However, Edwards failed to pull the trigger.
by Fort Worth on Jul 9, 2008 10:45 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
The fact that
Edwards performed as well as he did (as a rookie, no less) with a moribund offensive scheme in 2007 is a testament to his poise. That’s part of what sold this coaching staff on Edwards. If it wasn’t true, then J.P. would be our starter this season.
I see your point about the Dallas game, but let’s be fair about it. Edwards in his first MNF game against the famed Dallas team. He could have failed miserably, and tossed 4 picks. He didn’t, though. If you want to point fingers in that game, point them at the offense as a whole…
Get the Bills back to the big game!
by Blitz on Jul 9, 2008 11:16 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
1 pick is more than enough in the red zone
His ill timed pick towards the end of the game set up the Dallas comeback (along with a litle help from the refs—2 seconds for an onside kick???). Edwards doesn’t like to take what he feels are risky downfield shots so he throws a lot of dump offs instead. This proves that he’s smart enough to listen to the guy (Jauron) who decides on who starts at QB. Jauron has said often than any drive that ends with a kick isn’t all bad.
by Ron From NM on Jul 10, 2008 12:05 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
O.K., so he threw a pick in the red zone
Let me ask you, then. How many times did you see Joe Ferguson or Jim Kelly throw a pick in the red zone at a critical point in the game? Happens to the best of them…
I’ll gladly let you drape that mistake on the shoulders of a rookie QB. However, let’s not forget the rest of the team in the process.
Get the Bills back to the big game!
by Blitz on Jul 10, 2008 2:01 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
His pick cost the team the game
When a QB is playing on a team that is a work in progress said QB has to be smart with the ball. A field goal on that possession might have iced the game. Edwards generally is smart with the ball, hence the dump offs and his starting ahead of Losman. I’m not saying Edwards sucks. He’s exactly the type of QB Jauron wants—the type that doesn’t typically lose games for his team.
by Ron From NM on Jul 10, 2008 10:21 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
His pick certainly didn't help
but the special teams and defense let us down at the end of the game, too. My point is just that you can’t pin it on one guy from either of those like you can for the offense, but their failures were just as real, and cost the team just as much as that pick.
Get the Bills back to the big game!
by Blitz on Jul 11, 2008 4:19 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Quarterback Discussions
Why do I get the feeling that quarterback controversy and quarterback discussions in general are avoided on this blog? I don’t care what the media says. If I think that one player is better than another, hopefully I will have an opportunity to discuss it here. As long as comments are accurate, insightful, and respectful, why not?
Quarterback is the most important position on an NFL roster. The best teams have the best quarterbacks. I don’t understand why we don’t discuss the quarterback position more often on this blog.
by Fort Worth on Jul 9, 2008 10:14 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I wouldn’t say “avoided” so much as “rare”. I don’t mind talking about quarterbacks at all; I just try to space out the discussions on my end because they tend to be ridiculously repetitive. Variety, as they say, is the spice of life.
by Brian Galliford on Jul 9, 2008 12:25 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
TE, TE, TE
TE (and I don’t mean the QB’s initials) and maybe a little more FB help for Mr. TE will go a long way to making everyone on offense better.
by labill on Jul 9, 2008 11:31 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Ha! A kindred soul.
Couldn’t agree more, labill. You cannot essentially ignore two out of 11 positions on a squad and hope to have an effective offense. BOTH the TE and the FB have to be involved… in pass protection, run blocking, the run game, and contributing as receivers. Royal and Gaines had something like 50 catches between the two of them and we didn’t even have a FB last year.
Sure the QB is the most important position in professional sports, no less football. It’s also the most difficult to master. But Edwards has to have help from all ten of the other guys on the field.
by Defensewinsgames on Jul 9, 2008 5:07 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Seems like y’all are focusing more on the external than I did (even if I did mention play-calling first on the list). External help is great, but I’m of the opinion that Edwards needs personal growth more than anything. External help makes Edwards’ life easier, but ultimately, I was attempting to focus on what HE and he ALONE needs to do to improve quickly this season.
I’m floored that I’m the only one who’s voted for The Media to this point, too.
by Brian Galliford on Jul 9, 2008 12:24 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
The Media
One of the most important attributes that quarterbacks must possess is toughness, particularly mental toughness. This includes the ability to put aside external distractions such as the media and focus on the task at hand.
by Fort Worth on Jul 9, 2008 12:51 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
In that case, Experience
Edwards looked awful in the cold/rain/snow. Those also happened to be the latter games of the season. Was it the weather, or was it that he just declined later on as he played more (possibly overwhelmed?) or a combination of both? I connect Experience with Confidence (and it is possible that with more short-term hurried experience (at least last year), Edwards actually lost confidence). With all this time under him without the cramming that occured during the regular season, I think Confidence will improve all the other factors you mentioned (play calling, risk, leadership, media)
by labill on Jul 9, 2008 12:52 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Weather and better defenses
Edwards played in a blizzard, then played the defense that shut down Tom Brady and then played one of the most complex pressure defenses the league has ever seen. Now, he may have declined physically as the season wore on as well but credit the defenses he was playing, too.
by Ron From NM on Jul 10, 2008 12:08 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
It's experience. Hands down.
Look at Eli Manning. He played in the most harsh media scene of any quarterback. He publicly feuded with Tiki Barber. None of that really matters. A player knows what he can do when he has confidence in himself. Being comfortable in your own skin is built through experience, not public trial.
by jj24 on Jul 9, 2008 9:40 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Trusting his receivers
Maybe it was all in my head, but last season I thought I noticed that Trent would always stare down the receiver he was going to throw to. What I’d like to see more from him is trusting his receivers to be where they are supposed to and to trust in the timing of the routes and his drop steps to make reads and throws without following his target the whole way visually.
McKelvin and Hardy - rookies of the year
by poz on Jul 9, 2008 1:18 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Yeah
Some quarterbacks are not very good anticipation passers (see Donovan McNabb, Daunte Culpepper). They wait for their receivers to uncover before getting rid of the ball. They must see the throw.
Some other quarterbacks (see Drew Brees, Marc Bulger) make a living out of anticipation passing and often get rid of the ball before their receivers break out of their routes.
Over time, I expect Edwards to trust his receivers more and to improve in this area.
by Fort Worth on Jul 9, 2008 1:58 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
i don't know how you guys do it
but i just can’t discuss this stuff in a vacuum. there are an infinite number of keys to trent’s success next year, and we just won’t know which predominates until next year.
or at least until training camp.
i’m going to go with his beard though.
kept at an appropriate length, i think it could possibly carry us to the promised land.
by sri on Jul 9, 2008 1:50 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
The beard
I think he should grow it out like Johnny Damon did. You can’t go wrong with the Caveman/Jesus look.
The time has come for someone to put his foot down. And that foot is me.
by sireric on Jul 9, 2008 5:12 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I'm just a caveman!
Your world frightens and confuses me.
by jj24 on Jul 9, 2008 9:42 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
haha
Lionel Hutz: This is the greatest case of false advertising I’ve seen since I sued the movie The Never Ending Story
Lionel Hutz: Mr. Simpson, I don’t use the word ‘hero’ lightly, but you are the greatest hero in American history
Lionel Hutz: Well, he’s kind of had it in for me ever since I accidentally ran over his dog. Actually, replace “accidentally” with “repeatedly,” and replace “dog” with “son.”
by kaisertown on Jul 10, 2008 10:52 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 






















