Bills/Seahawks Film Review: Bills Offense
Each Tuesday this season, we here at Buffalo Rumblings will review the week's Buffalo Bills game on film (i.e. good old fashioned DVR) to get a little more in-depth perspective on how the Bills are performing. Special teams analysis immediately below this post; this is the offense, and the defense is coming.
We've already discussed the Buffalo Bills' offensive performance a bit this week, so rather than a blow-by-blow or general observations, I'd like to talk about a few individual players and units instead. Let's start with the quarterback, shall we?
Trent Edwards: I harp on consistency all the time, and it might be a bit cliche, but it's seriously the only thing holding Edwards back from becoming a proficient NFL quarterback. Reading defenses? He does that well already. Decision making? Already top notch. It's the intricacies of the game that are holding Edwards back at this point, and once he nails them down, he's going to be solid.
An area of particular concern for Trent is his streaky accuracy. There are points when he's in the zone and making outstanding throws, and there are also equal amounts of time where he's enough off to completely throw off the timing of a route. That will become less of an issue as he gains experience. Edwards was particularly awful at throwing screen passes Sunday; his throws come off high and on a hard line, and his backs routinely have balls skip off of their hands. If he can't resolve that, we might start seeing some tipped passes for interceptions.
All in all, though, you can tell the kid is bright. He's got what it takes to succeed, and more importantly, his teammates are behind him. Let's hope the kid stays healthy. And on that note...
Offensive Line: Ron from NM has done most of the heavy lifting here with his usual excellent O-Line analysis. I've just a couple of things to add: Buffalo's pass protection was excellent. I was impressed by the job that Kirk Chambers did in a lot of one-on-one pass protection against Patrick Kerney; the Pro Bowl end was a non-factor in this game (and on the one sack he did pick up, he beat Marshawn Lynch). Would like to see better run blocking, but I'm not particularly hopeful in that department. Can't wait to see how Jason Peters looks once he returns to the lineup.
Marshawn Lynch: Tony Boselli, who did color commentary for FOX's coverage of this game, loves Lynch's feet - and I completely agree. Much of the yardage that Lynch picked up in this game came via his impeccable ability to set up defenders once he hits the second level. This kid is something special, and what makes that even more exciting is that he's absolutely a team player. He has no issues with Fred Jackson stealing touches, and he's an incredibly willing blocker. The kid is just a lot of fun to watch, and he's only going to get better.
Lee Evans: It's pretty easy to tell that Evans isn't quite in sync with Edwards yet. Something about the way Edwards throw the balls - my best guess is release point - still bothers Evans; Lee dropped a few passes on Sunday and bobbled a couple more. He was also quite clearly out of bounds on his first long reception of the day (the one that led to Lynch's touchdown run), but we'll let that one slide - thanks, refs.
Still, Evans runs excellent routes, and it was plain that when Evans was lined up across from Seattle's Kelly Jennings, the Bills were going to attack it. The guy makes plays, and it was nice to see him doing it early in the game and early in the season. See what good play-calling does for an offense? It gets the ball into the hands of your best players. Evans needs to become a bit more reliable, but he also needs to get paid. Make it happen, Brandon.
Turk Schonert: I'll end the offensive analysis with Turk Schonert. I love this guy's instincts. We tend to forget that this was the first official game in which he'd called plays, and he called a pretty good game against a stingy Seahawks defense. He seems to have a much better feel than his predecessor - we shall call him Steve Fairchild-Mularkey - of knowing which player should get the ball in which situation. Once his offense can execute at a higher level, the guy might end up looking like a genius.
I particularly like Schonert's killer instinct. It was excellent to see the Bills' offense taking chances in big situations, which in 2007 would have been incredibly out of character for them. The field goal right before halftime to make the lead 20-7 at the break was huge, and of course, the 30-yard touchdown pass from Edwards to Robert Royal one play after a recovered fumble put the final nail in the coffin. Killer instinct will take this team a long way. Schonert's influence might be the most encouraging offensive sign to date.
Read Related
Comments
screen throws
why was that? Basically every screen throw Trent threw was way too powerful. You’d figure that would be one of the first things a young QB perfects. Oh well, he still looked great.
About Lee Evans, I think he is going to look much better with Trent than with JP. I think that while JPs arm played to Evans deep threat strength it also limited him to it. Trent is far more accurate and releases the ball fast and as Evans and the offense run different routes to capitalize on this style we will see Evans as a far more complete number 1 than just the explosive threat he was under Losman.
McKelvin and Hardy - rookies of the year
by poz on Sep 9, 2008 12:14 PM EDT 0 recs
Schonert's killer instinct
I love it too. I said before the Seahawks game that I was worried about playing to conservative. After game 1 I am no longer worried.
The time has come for someone to put his foot down. And that foot is me.
by sireric on Sep 9, 2008 12:27 PM EDT 0 recs
The 30-yard TD strike to Royal
after the fumble recovery by Lindell is a nice synopsis of the new offensive philosophy under Schonert. Does anybody care to hazard a guess about what the previous guys (SF-M) would have done with that opportunity? That’s part of what I like about Schonert – he’s bold when the occasion presents itself. Thanks, Turk, for vindicating my defense of you during the offseason.
Get the Bills back to the big game!
by Blitz on
Sep 9, 2008 12:38 PM EDT
up
0 recs
I'm going to go with run, run, 6 yard incompletion, FG.
by twoeightnine on
Sep 9, 2008 1:10 PM EDT
up
0 recs
hey two eight nine
nice photoshop on KSK with the Tom Brady patch…..hilarious!
~K
by Kurupt on
Sep 9, 2008 1:52 PM EDT
up
0 recs
Thanks.
I was wondering what Drew would eventually use it for. I was not disappointed.
by twoeightnine on
Sep 9, 2008 4:22 PM EDT
up
0 recs
I also liked
multiple deeper throws to Evans. More than just the 1 or 2 that SFM would call a game. The more we see these plays, the more the deep middle will open up for Roscoe, Reed and Hardy. It’s just a matter of time before we see some of those passes.
I still think Turk was somewhat conservative. A lot of the runs were right up the gut, and there were still a ton of short passes. I know Trent kept dumping them off, so it’s tough to tell how many were actually called short, but I think we have to work the middle more. If teams start playing 8 in the box or the LB’s don’t respect that middle passing game, we will see struggles from the O.
~K
by Kurupt on
Sep 9, 2008 1:51 PM EDT
up
0 recs
Also
What was that strange thing Trent did just before the Lynch touchdown run?
Was that a (gasp) audible?
The time has come for someone to put his foot down. And that foot is me.
by sireric on
Sep 9, 2008 2:53 PM EDT
up
0 recs
Turk is going to be the difference this year in at least 2 games
He will be the reason we end up being 10-6 instead of 8-8 or worse as we would have been with SFM calling the games still. Turk is not one to wait for the other team to adjust, he keeps changing things up to force the other team to adapt to him and his plays. Thats the sign of a GREAT offensive Coordinator. If we go 10-6 or better, Wilson had better pony up to Turk because we could lose him quick.
Fear the mighty helmet wearing gopher, he is coming for your soul....
by WABillsfan on
Sep 10, 2008 2:36 AM EDT
up
0 recs
The screen passes were disheartening, especially one where Lynch would have had a good gain, but I think it is equally important for Lynch to nab those throws. He may have had two drops if I recall.
Lynch in general looked good, but for whatever reason, maybe the run blocking of Fowler, we don’t have much of a between the tackle game running up the middle.
Edwards looked good. Not great, and not bad, but just good. He finds the receiver, and gets it away fairly quickly. The timing was off with Evans, but what I liked the most is that Edwards was throwing to Evans alot, and knwoing who your best player is and getting it to him is important. I also hope that in the hopefully nicer weather in Jacksonville, we’ll have some more success in the air, and maybe Hardy can get some more action.
Lastly, Schonert did call a good game, but not great. If that draw doesn’t go for six or even a first down we’d all be crowing. But hey, it worked beautifully, and maybe it s more of where and when than a redundancy in those situations. I’d like to see some more playaction in 3rd and short. I think the Denver game last night was an awesome display of playcalling by Mike Shannahan, and I think in terms of aggressiveness, Turk showed some signs of that.
The Bills CAN win every game
by killascript on Sep 9, 2008 12:33 PM EDT 0 recs
Edwards was particularly awful at throwing screen passes Sunday; his throws come off high and on a hard line, and his backs routinely have balls skip off of their hands.
Can you really fully blame Edwards here though? If he’s hitting his guys in the HANDS, they have to catch them. I know on the screens, he tends to throw them a bit hard, but still, Lynch and co. have to catch those. Trent will get better at those once we start utilizing them more. Lynch dropped another pass when he was hit just after he was getting the ball, but it would have been for a 1 yard gain, at most, so no biggie there.
Other than the sack, how did Lynch (and Freddie) look in blitz pickups???
Evans and Edwards….Evans has to make those catches. He seems to be bobbling a lot of passes the past year + 1 game, especially the deep ones. That’s not a place where you can say it’s anything related to Edwards, IMO. Once the ball is in the air on the deeper ones, release points/arm motion/whatever are thrown out the window. He also dropped that TD in the endzone early on, though it was tough to tell if the Seahawk CB knocked it away or not. One thing, Evans seems very comfortable catching passes from Edwards in the shorter areas, like the quick out for 10 yards he caught for his last catch of the day and the short pass over the middle he caught and turned upfield for 19 yards just before the half. I’m just concerned about him on the intermediate and deep passes. He never seemed to have trouble catching those cleanly before. That catch/no catch for his first grab was very close though. I’m not sure it was definitely out of bounds, as he had possession of it the whole time, just a quick juggle right away. I still think his feet were down….
Lynch is so close to breaking a big run, it seems nearly every time he gets space. It’s going to happen very soon, maybe the next few games (probably the Raiders, ha), and I can’t wait for it to happen. I REALLY, REALLY REALLY hope Turk continues finding ways to get it to him in space. Love the screen calls, we just have to execute them. I want more counters off-tackle, like the way Minnesota uses Purple Jesus. Let Marshawn use his power and speed, seems like he gets 10+ every time we run a play like that. With Peters back, we can run pulls and outside runs, IMO, than we could with Walker.
I think Trent was pretty consistent once the weather broke. It’s unfortunate, but I think he really struggles in the elements. He definitely has to work on that and be more confident in himself in those situations. We can’t have a poor weather QB here in Buffalo. I want to see more intermediate passes too. I can’t stand throwing 3-4 yard dumpoffs on 3rd and long. Why not throw it past the sticks? Who cares if it’s incomplete if you aren’t going to get it with the dumpoffs. Of course, if nothing is there, don’t force it, but also don’t settle for the short ones every time.
~K
by Kurupt on Sep 9, 2008 1:48 PM EDT 0 recs
Chambers
Would like to see better run blocking, but I’m not particularly hopeful in that department.
Bri, you mentioned that Chambers run blocking wasn’t a strength but as Ron’s OL assessment on gap running shows he and Butler were very effective (4.0 ypc – B Gap and 5.7 ypc – C Gap). Mind you it was only 6 running plays out of 28 but that is effective in my book.
by gatornation on Sep 9, 2008 2:06 PM EDT 0 recs
Good Numbers for the right side
I think Brian meant that run-blocking for the OL/TE/FB as a whole could be better. When he spoke of Chambers, it was specifically in regards to pass-blocking.
by south123 on Sep 9, 2008 2:39 PM EDT 0 recs
bills king of the east!
heres an awesome article i found. http://myespn.go.com/blogs/afceast/0-3-49/Domino-effect—How-Brady-s-knee-impacts-AFC.html
by billsstein on Sep 9, 2008 3:34 PM EDT 0 recs
Love it
I saw a few articles naming the jets as the new kings of the east. Of course, the Pats aren’t dead yet, but they are definitely beatable.
by Hopefulcynic on
Sep 9, 2008 10:50 PM EDT
up
0 recs

















