Back seven battles wide open in Buffalo
Unless an NFL coaching staff is in the first year (or two) of its current regime with their team, most NFL coaching staffs enter training camp and the pre-season with a pretty good idea of which 53 players will be on their team. Entering his fourth season at the helm of the Buffalo Bills, it's very likely that Dick Jauron and his coaching staff - most of whom have been here as long as he has - have a firm grasp on what their opening day roster will look like.
Injuries and unexpected performances obviously can change the game, but the general idea remains valid. These guys know who they'd like to go into battle with.
It's therefore unsurprising, then, that the Bills are essentially defined depth-wise at most offensive positions, as well as along the defensive line. The picture becomes much fuzzier, however, when talking about linebackers and defensive backs. The Bills have 24 players currently on their roster playing in their defensive back seven. 21 of them have very legitimate shots to make the roster.
Even breaking this down into general positions (outside linebacker, inside linebacker, cornerback, strong safety, free safety), the competition is fierce and the flexibility is envious. We've broken this down by position, and then placed every player into three categories: roster locks, in the hunt, or on the bubble.
Outside Linebacker
Locks: Kawika Mitchell, Keith Ellison, Nic Harris
- Mitchell and Ellison are locked in as starters. Harris, a fifth-round pick out of Oklahoma, has had a strong camp, looked very active in the Hall of Fame Game, and is a certainty to make the team. He might be the first linebacker off the bench if either starter goes down as well.
In the Hunt: Jon Corto, Ashlee Palmer, Alvin Bowen
- Corto has made a strong impression on the coaching staff - strong enough, in fact, to make him one of a very few players that the staff might try to force onto the roster. Palmer has opened some eyes with his raw athleticism as well, but no one is sure at this point how soon he'll be available after spraining his ankle against Tennessee. Jauron confirmed Tuesday night that he'd miss at least a week. Bowen had a strong pre-season performance as well; though he had fallen behind Palmer a bit in the pecking order, Palmer's injury gives Bowen another shot to make an impact now that he'll get more reps.
Inside Linebacker
Locks: Paul Posluszny
- Not a ton to add here. Pretty obvious, really.
In the Hunt: Pat Thomas, Marcus Buggs
- The beauty to these two players is that, while they've been taking middle linebacker reps pretty much exclusively throughout camp, both can play outside as well. Right now, we'd be inclined to say that Thomas is closer to making the roster than is Buggs - but Buggs has a bit more than a fighter's chance. The coaches like him, and he (as well as Thomas) give the team a boost on special teams.
So, yeah. Literally every linebacker on the roster - right now, there are nine of them - has a chance to end up on the final roster. Every single one of them. That clearly won't happen, but your guess as to which one (or two, or three) gets cut is as good as ours. Palmer's injury is very unfortunate.
Cornerback
Locks: Terrence McGee, Leodis McKelvin, Drayton Florence, Reggie Corner
- McGee and McKelvin are entrenched as the starters. The coaches have been very pleased with Florence; barring an injury to the veteran, the competition for the starting nickel role is all but over. Corner has had a very productive off-season to date (including a pick-six in the Hall of Fame Game), and he provides great depth and special teams ability.
In the Hunt: Ashton Youboty, Ellis Lankster
- At least one of these players will still be with the team. There's a chance both could stick. But each player is out of "lock" territory for different reasons; for Youboty, it's his injury history, and for Lankster it's his status as a vastly unproven seventh-round draft pick. Both players are obviously talented. They have some work to do, however, if they want to secure roster spots.
On the Bubble: Cary Harris, Lydell Sargeant
- Both of these rookies are listed here simply because the Bills are deep at this position. Both have talent, and the coaches obviously like both of them as well. One or both could wind up on the practice squad.
Free Safety
Locks: Donte Whitner, Jairus Byrd
- The safety position is wide open, folks. Whitner is the jack-of-all-trades defensive back of this team and a defensive co-captain; obviously, he stays. Byrd is a lock as well as a second-round draft pick, though as he's still recovering from sports hernia surgery and on the PUP list, questions remain as to how quickly he'll be able to contribute.
In the Hunt: Ko Simpson
- Byrd's injury has given Simpson an opportunity to take a lot of reps this pre-season, and he's been the second-team free safety throughout camp. He played well against the Titans. Depending on how the numbers game shakes out, Simpson is an experienced option with an excellent chance of making the roster - even though he's been a popular "cut" throughout the off-season.
On the Bubble: Antwain Spann
- The most Spann has done in his very short time with the team is get Dustin Fox waived. He's known for his special teams prowess, but how much of an 'in' does that give him when every safety on the roster can contribute in that area?
Strong Safety
Locks: Bryan Scott, George Wilson
- Some may be surprised to see Wilson's name here, but you shouldn't be - Wilson was a special teams captain last year, has outstanding leadership qualities, and can contribute defensively. I wouldn't be overly shocked to see him released, mind you - that's a testament to how closely contested the safety position is right now - but Wilson has things going for him that others just don't right now. Scott continues to impress as a run defender. He can play.
In the Hunt: John Wendling
- If there's one safety that has an 'in' as a specialist, it's Wendling, who for two years has been a key centerpiece to Bobby April's coverage units. The guy simply isn't going to contribute defensively, though, which takes him out of "lock" range. The coaches love him, though. The chances that he makes the team again as a pure specialist are quite good.
We just discussed 24 football players. Only three of them have less than a fighter's chance at making the final roster. At a bare minimum, the Bills are likely going to keep 16 of these players (a minimum of six linebackers, and a minimum of ten defensive backs). Y'all can try, if you like, to pick out five names to cut. Every player here can contribute in some way. The competition is wide open. This is a good problem for the Bills' coaching staff, but they've clearly got some difficult decisions to make.
16 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Those who go
Cary Harris
Marcus Buggs
Antwain Spann
Lydell Sargeant
Palmer or Youboty will be the other to go. Unless we get another, more serious injury before the end of preseason.
LOL, replying to Buffalo Mo and Dyl here.
Cary Harris, Antwain Spann and Lydell Sargeant are the three that are excluded from the list of 21.
Y’all are picking five from the rest of the names as cuts. Gets a bit more difficult, eh? :)
Buffalo Rumblings. On Twitter.
"Our style is simple but not that easy. Roll up your sleeves and play good, solid football." -- Marv Levy
by Brian Galliford on Aug 12, 2009 3:17 PM EDT up reply actions
It Certainly Does.
- Buggs is still gone
- They trade Youboty for a 6th/7th rounder or hes cut
- Wendling is gone
- Palmer is gone
- They cut Xavier Omen in order to keep the rest.
They won’t cut Omon because of Lynch’s suspension. Hall gets the axe.
Delightfully Ignoring The Truth since 1995.
by NeverendingOptimism on Aug 12, 2009 3:56 PM EDT up reply actions
What happens to Omen with Lynch is back?
Put Bowen in PS….then Cut Omen and bring Bowen back once Lynch is back?
I think Omon is on the team til Lynch gets back then he immediately goes down to PS. UNLESS he has gained like 5 TD before Lynch returns…
Unlikely, but a nice fantasy.
I did like Omon in the the Titans game, though. He showed me something.
by Defensewinsgames on Aug 12, 2009 5:58 PM EDT up reply actions
I think you made the right call placing Wilson on the list of locks. Not only is he the ST captain, but he had a pretty specialized role as that deep blocker on the punt unit and was great covering punts from that position.
How close was Pat Thomas to being a lock? The inexperience at linebacker is pretty crazy with Thomas on the roster. I can’t imagine him not making the team.
Palmer’s injury is unfortunate, but I think it makes him an easy stash on the PS. I think that we as fans tend to think that our guys getting poached off the PS is far more likely than it actually is.
Ummm....
I think you forgot to mention a factor that Ko Simpson has in his favor: he’s worth millions.
Buggs is gone
Palmer is forced onto PS because of a nagging injury
Simpson – so long as Byrd isn’t nagged by injury
Youboty, traded
Bowen PS – only if they want to keep Lankster to make sure he doesn’t get grabbed by another team
Correction – I went through my projections for the final roster and I don’t think Wendling makes it. Though as of right now I am not taking off any of the other 5 – so there Brian, I was able to get rid of 6!
If only 6 linebackers:
Bowen, Palmer and Buggs are cuts, with as many of them on the PS as possible.
and then I’d cut Wendling and Simpson and stash Spann on the PS. Our safeties are not nearly as injury prone as our CBs.
It would be a shame to get rid of Wendling, but being a special teams demon is just not enough, otherwise we would still have Stamer, Costanzo et al. Plus I love what I’ve seen of Corto on ST.
What can we get for Booty?
We have had good luck with 6th and 7th picks; he could potentially be traded or cut due to a 7th.
"Hold ya chin up...nuh nuh nuh...gone"
-Marshawn Lynch-
My Useless Take on The Situation...
(6) LBs kept: Poz, Mitchell, Ellison, Harris, Thomas, Buggs
-Palmer cut (to PS)
-Bowen cut (to PS)
-Corto cut (to PS if eligible)
(5) CBs kept: McGee, McKelvin, Florence, Corner, Lankster
-Youboty traded (only becuz of G’s insight)
-Harris cut
-Sargeant cut
(2 or 3) FSs kept: Whitner, Byrd
-Spann cut (to PS if eligible)
(2 or 3) SSs kept: Scott, Wilson
-Simpson/Wendling is too close to call (depends on the rest of preseason and what they do with Lankster/Youboty)
by NorCal BillsFan on Aug 13, 2009 1:24 PM EDT reply actions

by 















