Recapping week one of Buffalo Bills training camp
The Buffalo Bills are now nine practices deep into 2009 training camp, and after eight full days of hard work, the entire team is getting Sunday off to rest and recuperate. The pads go back on on Monday as the team prepares for its first pre-season game of the year, which takes place a week from today in the Hall of Fame Game.
A lot has happened to this point - in terms of players performing (or not), in terms of lineup surprises, and in terms of who is not in camp. We were fortunate to have representation at camp seven days, and have recaps here for those in the reviewing mood: Day 1, Day 2, Day 3, Day 4, Day 5, Day 6, Day 7. (You'll have to rely on bigger-name sources for Day 8 coverage; we'll be back camping next week.)
This post is not intended to recap every significant development; you'd be reading for the rest of the afternoon if that was the case. Instead, we'll focus on each position after the jump, giving you some of our general impressions based on what we've seen and heard, with a specific focus on the big story lines for the Bills heading into the regular season.
Quarterback. Trent Edwards is looking pretty comfortable. Not all of his throws have been pretty - defensive backs have made a lot of plays on his passes, actually - but the encouraging sign is that he's making many more big plays himself. He and Terrell Owens have quickly established a good on-field rapport, though, as with Edwards and any other player, the rest of the relationship is a work in progress. Trent's also looking more comfortable making his reads and with his footwork. Signs are encouraging. Meanwhile, steady improvement has been the name of the game for backup Ryan Fitzpatrick. He was awful when camp opened, but has leveled off to the point where we don't have to have nightmares about our backup QB situation every night.
Running Back. Marshawn Lynch looks great. He is his usual explosive (in the short area), difficult-to-tackle self. Fred Jackson has been pulling off his best Swiss Army knife impression, running the Wildcat and catching passes as a receiver in addition to his running back duties. Veteran free agent signee Dominic Rhodes is in great shape, running hard, and looks quick with the ball in his hands. He is easily the best receiver of this group; even when Lynch returns, Rhodes will get playing time.
Fullback. Nothing to see here. The position has been completely eradicated from Buffalo's offense as they transition to the no-huddle, and if Corey McIntyre wants to make the team, he'll have to do it as a specialist.
Wide Receiver. Terrell Owens has been outstanding. The man, quite simply, is a freak. His skills don't look diminished a bit, no matter what the "experts" tell you. As long as he's happy this season, the man will produce. Lee Evans is his usual self. Josh Reed is going to have a monster year, folks, provided Owens and Evans are on the field. He might lead the team in catches. Seriously. Before injuring his ribs, Steve Johnson was off to a great start as well. He's got a bright future. Roscoe Parrish has been running the Wildcat in an effort to find ways to get the ball in his hands offensively. One young receiver has been impressing as well - Shaine Smith might be just a street free agent, but he's been making plays, and is very long and athletic. Keep your eye on him.
Tight End. Derek Schouman currently has the inside track to start over the more talented, yet slightly less polished Derek Fine. Schouman looks quite impressive - he's a reliable short-area receiver, and his blocking has been outstanding thus far in camp. He routinely handles defensive ends with ease. Jonathan Stupar is a similar player, and he's been very solid throughout the first week as well. He might find a way to sneak onto the roster. Shawn Nelson is currently dealing with a foot injury, but his outstanding athleticism is apparent when he's on the field. He's easily got the softest pair of hands of this group, and he's a willing, yet highly unpolished blocker. His impact might not be immediate, but Nelson will be a player in this league.
Offensive Tackle. Outside of quarterback, this area has easily been the biggest worry for the fan base, but Langston Walker and Brad Butler are playing well. Butler has struggled some with bull rushes, but he's still re-learning tackle techniques, so that's to be expected. Once he fixes pad level issues, he'll be fine. These two are known commodities and play consistently, so as long as their shortcomings aren't anything more than physical - and thus far, they haven't been - the Bills should be alright offensively. Demetrius Bell has shown tremendous improvement in his second year; you're going to see him on the field a ton in the pre-season. Jonathan Scott has been solid as well, and has a shot to make the roster.
Offensive Guard. Eric Wood is a freaking monster. He's huge, athlhetic, strong, and tenacious. He's a leader. Buffalo's offensive line has been physically talented over the past few years, but there wasn't any leadership up front. Wood is that player. He might be an offensive captain next year; the kid oozes leadership. Andy Levitre has been impressive as well, though not anywhere near the level Wood has; Levitre is improving, but don't be surprised if he's beaten out for the starting left guard job by Kirk Chambers, a dependable veteran who doesn't make a lot of mistakes. Levitre has some growing up to do. Seth McKinney doesn't stand a chance to beat out Wood at right guard, but he's been solid as well, and he'll be a valuable reserve this season.
Center. Geoff Hangartner, unsurprisingly, has picked up the intricacies of Buffalo's no-huddle offense quickly. There isn't an awful lot to report here, as we've had a tough time keeping an eye on him, but no news isn't necessarily bad news. Brandon Rodd has been getting second-team reps at center; he's a big, thick kid that in all likelihood will end up back on the practice squad. He has some talent.
Defensive End. Chris Kelsay, surprisingly, has been the bright spot. Chalk it up to going up against Butler in practice if you'd like, but Kelsay has recorded numerous sacks and pressures, and his run defense has always been solid (when he's not getting faked out on a misdirection play, that is). Aaron Schobel is showing no ill effects of his Lisfranc foot injury, though he hasn't been particularly effective rushing against Walker in practice. Chris Ellis is looking great as a reserve; his upper body strength has improved tremendously, and he looks pretty quick out on the field. He might be ready to make an impact. Still, Aaron Maybin cannot get here fast enough - this is not an athletic group of people.
Defensive Tackle. Marcus Stroud is Marcus Stroud. Nothing to worry about here - the guy can play. Kyle Williams has been borderline dominant to this point; he might now take the crown as the Bills' best pure run defender. John McCargo was putting together some nice work before a hamstring injury sidelined him. This group isn't particularly deep (Spencer Johnson helps, of course), but all four of these guys can play. If there's a young player to be stashed on the practice squad for depth in the event of an injury, it's David Lindquist.
Outside Linebacker. Kawika Mitchell has looked solid on the weak side, and Keith Ellison has found himself making plays in the backfield on more than one occasion on the strong side. No one has come close to unseating Ellison for his starting job. Nic Harris has flashed some promise as a reserve, but his technique work currently leaves a lot to be desired. Alvin Bowen and Ashlee Palmer are easily the best athletes at this position; they're quite fast, and both have a chance to make the roster as reserves and specialists. Don't count out Jon Corto, either - he's revered by Bobby April, and he's not a bad linebacker, either.
Inside Linebacker. Paul Posluszny has been outstanding against the run, and he looks far more comfortable defending the pass and blitzing than he did a year ago. He's much, much less tentative. Pat Thomas and Marcus Buggs have been splitting second-team reps at the position, with Thomas looking a hair better. We're going to miss John DiGiorgio, however; he's a much more physical defender than either Thomas or Buggs.
Cornerback. Just like with any veteran, you can safely say that Terrence McGee has been his usual self. Not many big plays, but a lot of pass break-ups and few big plays given up. Leodis McKelvin, on the other hand, has been far more up-and-down, and he's spent a lot more time down than up. Owens and Evans are brutalizing this kid. Here's to hoping it doesn't ruin his confidence. On the other hand, he's also made some beautiful plays, including a couple of gorgeous interceptions. Once Leo gets himself consistent, he's going to be quite the ball player. The battle at nickel corner rages on, but only technically - Drayton Florence has distanced himself early from Reggie Corner and Ashton Youboty (and right now, we'd place Corner slightly ahead of Youboty as well, but that should change quickly once the team starts playing games). Ellis Lankster continues to surprise; he's a great athlete.
Free Safety. Donte Whitner has seen every first-team rep here, and that's not likely to change for a long, long time. Buffalo's coaching staff is very anxious to get Jairus Byrd onto the field, but as he's currently on the PUP list recovering from sports hernia surgery, the idea that he'd line up next to Whitner as a starter is borderline absurd. Ko Simpson has been dependable as the second-team safety, though his climb to a roster spot is still an uphill one. Antwain Spann, recently signed from the Patriots, will be watched with interest over the next couple of weeks - he's got some talent, but his role has yet to be clearly defined.
Strong Safety. Bryan Scott has been excellent, recording a few interceptions and taking one back for a score. He's even gotten some reps here and there at linebacker, in the event that the Bills have to deal with a bunch of injuries there. George Wilson has made some nice plays running with the twos at this position. John Wendling appears to be nothing more than a solid run defender and specialist; we still maintain that he, too, should make a move to linebacker.
Specialists. Rian Lindell is Rian Lindell. Brian Moorman is Brian Moorman - but circa a few years ago, when he was awesome, and not last year, when he was just very good. Ryan Neill and Garrison Sanborn will duke it out for the long-snapping duties, but let's be honest, we're not at camp to watch long snappers. We'll chart them both during pre-season games. One last note - Leodis McKelvin has looked absolutely fantastic returning kicks. He's in line for a possible Pro Bowl season in that department.
37 comments
|
3 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I think I was wrong about Schouman. I didn’t think he could play in this league simply because he was a very poor blocker and undersized. Now that he’s added strength and bulk, and improved his technique, he really seems to be coming into his own. Good on him. His very underrated athleticism gives him a shot to be pretty good this year. I hope he does it.
I’m thinking Stupar is in right now, especially if Nelson isn’t likely to contribute immediately and CMFB is cut…
I wouldn’t call Walker and Butler known commodities. Maybe at their previous positions, but not now. When Walker played LT in Oakland, he was bad. And Butler hasn’t played RT at the pro level. These are two giant question marks, and I’d hardly say what they’ll give us at their new positions is known.
Of course Kelsay is playing well. This is his domain. He is the epitome of a practice hero. It’s when the lights come on and the games mean something where he shrinks and disappears. Nobody works harder than him in practice, which I do credit him for, but the games are where it counts and he doesn’t perform there.
I have been a bit shy to say it but I think Williams is our best DT. I was not impressed with Stroud last year; he was solid and his blend of sheer size/athleticism is awe-inspiring, but he was underwhelming last year. After week 1, we barely heard his name called all season. Williams makes plays, Stroud needs to this year.
McGee is so consistent and underrated. There’s another reason Leo is the one being consistently picked on, besides his inconsistencies, and that’s McGee. Glad to see Florence playing well. I really think he’ll be a quality nickel for us, just like he was in SD. I hope Youboty distances himself from Corner soon too, we need him on the field making plays.
With Scott getting some LB reps, that’s increases the chance we only keep 6 LB’s, which is fine with me. Wendling would be one athletic LB, but I don’t think he has the instincts to play it.
Nice recap Brian
~K
"As the governor of Louisiana once said, the only way Chris Kelsay can lose his job is if he got caught in bed with a dead girl or a live boy."
Stroud did lead the team with tipped passes at the line last year – a very under rated skill. Not to say Stroud is a complete dominant force but that ability helps especially since he is also a good run stopper. But I do like Williams a lot. I also think Stroud playing against Wood should be fun to watch in training camp.
The main thing about our DT is without a good helping hand from our DE then they will never be as good as they can be. Let’s face if you know the middle is the best part then you run to the outside or if Stroud/Williams breaks the middle the QB just runs out of the pocket where none of our DE has containment…
especially on a team
that can’t get off the line of scrimmage and into the backfield lol
Later Losman!
I wouldn’t call Walker and Butler known commodities.
Clarification: I meant that they’re known commodities purely in the sense that the coaches have been around them and know what to expect.
Buffalo Rumblings. On Twitter.
"Our style is simple but not that easy. Roll up your sleeves and play good, solid football." -- Marv Levy
by Brian Galliford on Aug 2, 2009 2:35 PM EDT up reply actions
A very helpful summary of where things stand
I hope that’s right about Schouman, but it has also been true in the past that he has performed well in practice only to disappoint in the regular season. Let’s cross our fingers that this is his breakthrough year. As Kurrupt points out, the same has been true for Kelsay, but it could be that the new d-line coach is going to make a big difference for him.
I’m always surprised when people are surprised at how good Bryan Scott is. He is a tremendous asset to this team, which makes one wonder why there would be talk of having Whitner go back to SS and taking Scott off the field. I know Byrd is going to be an excellent FS in due course, but I’m still puzzled as to why the Bills drafted him when they had more pressing needs on the d-line. Perhaps he is meant as an alternative to resigning Whitner if the Bills decide he’s not worth the high salary that would probably require.
In any event, Brian’s fine report suggests that things are looking up. Let’s hope and pray that what happens in Canton next Sunday confirms that.
the same has been true for Kelsay, but it could be that the new d-line coach is going to make a big difference for him.
I sincerely hope so. He really can’t be any less productive, so any improvement would be welcome.
~K
"As the governor of Louisiana once said, the only way Chris Kelsay can lose his job is if he got caught in bed with a dead girl or a live boy."
good stuff
this is awesome to finally be talking position battles and real padded football. This Eric Wood has impressed from the day we drafted him. He’s tough, no excuses, hard worker, blue collar, and just epitomizes everything you want in an OL and a football player. I tell you, Levitre and Byrd have pretty high expectations being 2nd round picks. And right now, the jury is very much out on these two guys and I’m real eager to see if either will contribute to Buffalo’s team significantly in 2009. I wonder if Bell would have any shot of winning the LG spot?
I love our DB’s, but our ability to pressure the QB and the play of our safeties is the key to producing big plays. I still highly question Whitner and what Jauron has in mind for that back end of that defense….a Scott/Whitner combo is average at best.
MARVelous - "I went from America's team to North America's Team" Terrell Owens
Bell has taken zero reps at LG.
No way he plays there.
Playing Realistic Optimist at Buffalo Rumblings since 2008. Fear can hold you prisoner. Hope can set you free.
by MattRichWarren on Aug 2, 2009 2:14 PM EDT up reply actions
I thought I read he’s getting reps at OT and G….I’ll have to search for that if it’s true….
~K
"As the governor of Louisiana once said, the only way Chris Kelsay can lose his job is if he got caught in bed with a dead girl or a live boy."
Aha
Also during individual position drills Demetrius Bell got some reps at left and right guard as that is still a potential position for him in addition to tackle.
"It’s a realistic option for me," said Bell. "For me it’s good to know more than one position. I feel the coaches did a good job of getting me ready to do that and I have no problem playing the position if I have to."
Weren’t you at the first practice?!?!
~K
"As the governor of Louisiana once said, the only way Chris Kelsay can lose his job is if he got caught in bed with a dead girl or a live boy."
Yes.
But I don’t remember it. He hasn’t taken any since Levitre and Wood got there I don’t think.
Playing Realistic Optimist at Buffalo Rumblings since 2008. Fear can hold you prisoner. Hope can set you free.
by MattRichWarren on Aug 2, 2009 5:01 PM EDT up reply actions
Thank you Brian, I haven’t had much time to read up on camp so that was a great recap of the week. Wish there was more competition for Ellison, and hope Levitre doesn’t get beat out.
New York City Buffalo Bills Backers
www.nycbbb.com
It’s not that there is no competition for Ellison. Harris especially has been playing well for a rookie. Ellison has been playing really well, too. We’ll see what happens in Canton.
Playing Realistic Optimist at Buffalo Rumblings since 2008. Fear can hold you prisoner. Hope can set you free.
by MattRichWarren on Aug 2, 2009 5:02 PM EDT up reply actions
Shaine Smith
Shaine Smith went to Hofstra. That’s the same college that produced Marques Colston, another unknown who has become one of the best wideouts in the league for the Saints. And Colston has attributed his success to the WR coach at Hofstra, Jaime Elizondo. I believe another of Elizondo’s recent proteges is now playing for the Lions. This could be interesting.
interesting
I will keep that in mind…nice info
Guards Brad Butler and Brandon Rodd are decent. - Pete Prisco
Brandon Rodd!! Our best player.
by poz on Aug 2, 2009 7:44 PM EDT up reply actions
would like more detail on a few things
Great write up, thanks for recapping Brian.
A few things I would like some more information on and this can come from anyone (I’m looking at you here MRW) who knows:
1.
Josh Reed is going to have a monster year, folks, provided Owens and Evans are on the field. He might lead the team in catches. Seriously.
You can not just say that and not explain why you would say something that seems quite outrageous. Terrell Owens and Lee Evans are both very good and to imply that Reed stands a good chance to grab more balls than BOTH of them itself implies that our offense has changed mightily. Are we going to see a lot more 3 WR sets? Are you throwing more? Are defenses so distracted by Evans and Owens that the coaching staff is banking on using Reed a lot? More on this please! More catches than both!!
2. Would it be a surprise if Bell starts at RT and Butler slides back to LG?
3. Did Leo show improvement against Evans and Owens as the week went on?
4. Is it possible Chris Kelsay has heard the now incredibly loud criticism of him this off-season and has been working hard to silence the critics? Many are saying McCargo is responding to new coaching on the d-line, could the same be said of Kelsay?
Thanks!
Guards Brad Butler and Brandon Rodd are decent. - Pete Prisco
Brandon Rodd!! Our best player.
meant Butler slides back to RG
Guards Brad Butler and Brandon Rodd are decent. - Pete Prisco
Brandon Rodd!! Our best player.
by poz on Aug 2, 2009 7:44 PM EDT up reply actions
Wood is doing so well at RG, I doubt they mess with him
If Bell goes to to RT, I would guess Butler goes to LG.
"I BET YOU IF WE PUT A 12 DOZEN GLAZE DONUTS AT THE OTHER END ON KICK RETURN JAIME DUKES WILL BE OUR NUM # 1 RETURNER …… HOW YOU LIKE THEM APPLES DUKE APPLE PIE PUNKEN EATER DWINKE SMASHER DING DONG FLABER" - abayarde
Folks, Demetrius Bell is not going to be a starting offensive lineman. NOT going to start.
Buffalo Rumblings. On Twitter.
"Our style is simple but not that easy. Roll up your sleeves and play good, solid football." -- Marv Levy
by Brian Galliford on Aug 2, 2009 9:47 PM EDT up reply actions
1. Reed has shown a propensity to get open underneath and Edwards has shown a willingness to throw it to the underneath receiver. There have been a lot of 3 WRs, 1 TE sets, 1 RB .
2. It would be a surprise if Bell starts anywhere unless there is an injury.
3. Leo had some good plays during the week. His problem is going to be doing that consistently.
4. Could be. We’ll have to see in real games.
Playing Realistic Optimist at Buffalo Rumblings since 2008. Fear can hold you prisoner. Hope can set you free.
by MattRichWarren on Aug 2, 2009 8:23 PM EDT up reply actions
Reed would have led the team in catches last year had he not missed 3 games to injury. With Evans and Owens occupying multiple defenders and running more deep routes, along with Trent’s love for the underneath stuff, it wouldn’t be surprising if Reed led the team in catches (while finishing third in yards). It could happen simply because of how much Trent loves throwing to him…
~K
"As the governor of Louisiana once said, the only way Chris Kelsay can lose his job is if he got caught in bed with a dead girl or a live boy."
Good point.
Reed would have led the team in catches last year had he not missed 3 games to injury.
Playing Realistic Optimist at Buffalo Rumblings since 2008. Fear can hold you prisoner. Hope can set you free.
by MattRichWarren on Aug 2, 2009 9:57 PM EDT up reply actions
with owens and evans
pushing the safeties back into a cover 2 or cover 3, instead of the usual jam on evans with a safety over top, the middle of the field is going to be a lot more open for the slot to find the soft spots in the zone, teams know that playing man up press with t.o. and lee big game evans will be there demise. teams are going to play a soft zone and make an unproven young quarterback beat them. cue the nfl films music and i’m jacked for sunday.
Later Losman!
Protection, Protection and more Protections.
I still believe if we can give Edwards three seconds of protection he will eat you alive. He seems to be more comfortable in the pocket and if he has those three seconds someone has to be open. Hangartner, Wood and who ever the right gaurd is just sounds like it will be there.
Well thank heavens.......the chicken littles can relax for a bit LOL
Meanwhile, steady improvement has been the name of the game for backup Ryan Fitzpatrick. He was awful when camp opened, but has leveled off to the point where we don’t have to have nightmares about our backup QB situation every night.
Godspeed Nick - RIP - 1986-2009
by norcaliangelsfan on Aug 2, 2009 10:07 PM EDT reply actions
This is one of the best articles I've ever seen on Rumblings.
Thank you Brian for the detailed write up, and thank you Matt for the incredible training camp reporting. You guys rock.
It interests me to see that Rhodes is our best pass receiving RB
Lynch and Jackson were the leading receiving tandem in the NFL last year (90 catches between the two). If Rhodes is even in the ballpark with these two, it might tear a hole in the natural order.
Jackson has been spreading out wide a lot. That may be where he gets his touches. Rhodes and Lycnh will be getting theirs from the backfield.
Playing Realistic Optimist at Buffalo Rumblings since 2008. Fear can hold you prisoner. Hope can set you free.
by MattRichWarren on Aug 3, 2009 11:11 AM EDT up reply actions
Great recap Brian
Between this recap and Matt’s tweets from camp last week, I’ve been able to catch up to a good degree without feeling like I completely missed out last week. The camp coverage has been top-notch fellas – I salute you!
It seems, based on what I’m reading, the two biggest “on-the-field” concerns right now are the offensive line (duh!) and the pass rush (if Maybin is not in camp very soon, he’s going to lose much of the "learning time" that is so vital to even a semi-productive rookie season).
I still believe that regardless of talent (and that includes the o-line) this whole season rests in the hands of the coaching staff. If Schonert doesn’t become less predictable and more diverse play-caller, this team is going to struggle. If Jauron hasn’t learned how to play to win or judicially use his time-outs, this team is going to struggle. If Fewell can’t find a way to produce a pass-rush, this team is going to struggle. Bottom line: There is enough talent on this team to win; the onus now rests on the coaching staff to make this team a winner.
John I.
If Jauron hasn’t learned how to play to win or judicially use his time-outs, this team is going to struggle.
Well, he’s been a head coach for 8+ seasons now. Since he hasn’t learned by now, it probably isnt’ happening…
~K
"As the governor of Louisiana once said, the only way Chris Kelsay can lose his job is if he got caught in bed with a dead girl or a live boy."

by 























