Marty Schottenheimer or Bill Cowher? That is the question.

Marty: 200 wins - 126 losses - 1 tie (.613 win%) 5 -13 (.278%) in playoffs.

Billy: 149 wins - 90 losses - 1 tie (.623 win%) 12 - 9 (.571%) in playoffs (2 Superbowls (1-1)).

Marty - 66 years old

Billy - 52 years old

Important notes - Marty gave Bill his first coaching gig as a special teams and then secondary coach in Cleveland in the late 80's. Both are great motivators and both are familiar with the region. Marty played in Buffalo as a linebacker in the late 60's and coached in near by Cleveland. Cowher played and coached in Cleveland, and of course coached in not so distant Pittsburgh. 

So who do you want as coach of the Bills? Assuming of course it comes down to these two fine coaches.