Power Ranking - Memorial Day - COMPLETED AND EXTENSIVE

First Power Ranking - in a series of power rankings for the rest of the season.  Will do one now, one before the preseason, and one before the start of the regular season.  REC if you like post.

Second part to be completed Tuesday.

Power ranking is based on the following:
Head-coach + coaching staff
Roster - specifically QB, LT, and defensive play makers
NFL Draft
Ownership and franchise philosophy
Experience and last year's success - is the team weaker or stronger?


    Significant Coaches:  Jim Caldwell (HC) and Larry Coyer (DC)
    QB:  Peyton Manning
    LT:  Charlie Johnson
    Defensive Play Makers:  Dwight Freeney, Robert Mathis, Bob Sanders

    The Colts are the model franchise.  They build through the draft, have the perfect franchise QB, and defensive play-makers.  Their greatest need going into the off-season is left tackle, this need has yet to be filled.  Either that, or the team is confident in Charlie Johnson coming off a year of experience.  Peyton Manning is still their, and the defensive will continue to improve with Larry Coyer at defensive coordinator.  This is not the same Colts team that we are used to seeing.  The defensive schemes use more man coverage and various blitzes.  The Colts strengthened their defensive pass rush depth by selecting Jerry Hughes and added depth to all other positions.  The Colts continue to be the Superbowl Favorites


    Significant Coaches:  Dom Capers (DC)
    QB:  Aaron Rodgers
    LT:  Chad Clifton
    Defensive Play Makers:  Clay Matthews, Al Harris, Charles Woodson

    Before the playoffs began - the Packers were favorites to go to the Superbowl.  In the middle of the offseason the Packers are my favorites to win the NFC.  The biggest weakness the Packers displayed against the Cardinals were LT, and defensive pressure.  The Packers not only resigned both of their tackles, but also landed one of the elite tackles with Bryan Bulaga in the draft.  Kapman's departure was filled with Mike Neal, and the aging secondary was aided by drafting Morgan Burnett.  Aaron Rodgers will be the best QB this season and will help Packers fans quickly forget Brett Favre.  Capers defensive scheme brings heavy pressure on opposing QBs.


    Coaches:  Sean Payton
    QB:  Drew Brees
    LT:  Jamaal Brown
    Defensive Play Makers:  Darren Sharper

    Defending champs look solid.  They get the majority of their roster back - and the most significant loss is Mike Bell.  They also had a great draft.  Charles Brown is a project but will eventually replace Jamaal Brown at LT.  Jimmy Graham is an ultra athletic TE and if Shockey has health issues - he will be a great replacement next season.  Patrick Robinson is a great cover corner to add depth to a strong secondary.  The Saints did not bolster their defensive line to help stop the run


    QB:  Joe Flacco
    LT:  Michael Oher
    Defensive Play Makers:  Ray Lewis, Haloti Ngata, Ed Reed

    The Ravens - the team that the Jets try to emulate are still better than the Jets and had a fantastic off season.  Joe Flacco will improve.  The running game will improve.  The young offensive line has experience.  The defense has experience, and has gained an extensive youth influx.  Drafting Terrence Cody will make the entire defense that much better - with Cody gobbling up offensive lineman - the defense will be free to wreck havok.  I love Sergio Kindle - he adds talent and youth to an aging linebacker group.  All the Ravens front office did was improve weapons for Flacco to pass to.  They added Anquin Boldin and drafted Dickson, and Pitta in the draft - not to mention resigning all their current wide receivers.  I love everything the Ravens do.  They built their team on a suffocating defense, then drafted a franchise QB, then drafted a franchise LT to protect him.


    QB:  Phillip Rivers
    LT:  Marcus McNeil
    Defense:  Shaun Phillips

    The Chargers have moved pass the LT era by drafting Mr. Matthews.  Ryan Matthews is a tough three down runner who brings much needed fresh legs to the chargers offense.  Although the offense is transforming into more of a pass happy scheme - Matthews will immediately help take pressure off Rivers.  The defense is my greatest issue as the Chargers played the run very poorly.  I hope bringing in Cam Thomas helps - but he slipped for a reason.  I do like the Darrell Stuckey pick and hope that Butler can help improve their run defense.  Shawn Merriman has one last chance to prove his worth.


    Jason Garret
    QB:  Tony Romo
    LT:  ???
    Defense:  Demarcus Ware, Marcus Spears

    TO leaves and Tony Romo improves.  In fact the Cowboys offense is playing very well and balances the running game with the passing game - thank Jason Garret.  The defense plays very well - shutting out the Eagles multiple times last season.  However they looked weak against the Vikings.  I love the Cowboys draft.  I love Dez Bryant catching passes from Tony Romo and I love Sean Lee to anchor the middle of this defense.  Owusu-Ansah is a fantastic prospect who can play both safety and corner.  I don't know how I feel about Sam Young....
    Biggest weakness lies in the offensive line.  Second biggest weakness is how poorly they play against the pass - as seen by Favre's fun.


    QB:  Tom Brady
    Matt Light
    Defense:  Vince Wilfork the great, Ty Warren

    As long as Tom Brady is the QB and Bill is the coach - the Patriots are the best team in the AFC East - unless of course Bill has really lost his touch.  Vince Wilfork is the best NT in the NFL and his presence changes the entire defensive attack of the team.  Randy Moss and Welker will come back healthy and the emergence of some of the young offensive players make this a more dangerous offensive team.  Defensively - they needed to improve their secondary.  Offensively they need a better running game.  Tom Brady's dedication to the team is questionable - but he is still Tom Brady. 


    Brett Favre
    LT:  Bryan McKinne
    Defense:  Pat Williams, Kevin Williams, Jared Allen

    Brett Favre electing to do surgery indicates that he will most probably return and that instantly makes the Vikings a superbowl contender.  The Vikings were great last season and lets see if they can duplicate their success.  They need to run the ball more often - they relied on Brett Favre too much at times.  With Adrian Peterson on your team, how can you not want to run the ball.  I love their off season.  Although they lost Chester Taylor - I love drafting Toby Gerhart as a tough between the tackles runner.  Will take the physical beating away from Peterson.  I love Chris Cook - who will instantly improve the defensive secondary and add an important play maker.  Griffen is a steal in the third round and he will instantly add pressure opposite Jared Allen.


    Rex Ryan, Bryan Schottenheimer
    QB:  Mark Sanchez
    LT:  D Ferguson
    Defensive:  Shaun Ellis, Jason Taylor, Bart Scott, Darrel Revis, Antonio Cromartie

    The most celebrity, active, and "cool" team this off season - the Jets off season moves are over rated.  The Jets have improved their receiving core - no doubt.  They have improved an already fantastic secondary, and they have improved their defense.  But there are a few question marks.  Are the Jets the new Redskins.  I think the running game went downhill.  I love LT BUT does he have anything left in his legs?  Shonne Green was a pleasant playoff surprise but other than that has not done anything special.  Two other running backs were lost in favor of Joe McKnight.  Mark Sanzhez has a whole year of tape for coaches to study.  Faneca was released.  Jason Taylor is also old.  I'm sure the Jets have what it takes - but with question marks at QB and RB - in order to become elite - I still do not view the Jets as the favorites to win the AFC.


    QB:  Carson Palmer
    LT:  Andre Smith
    Defense:  Ray Maulaga

    The Bengals played great last season but they were missing the swagger and the big play ability to move to the next level and become elite contenders.  I think with one year of experience and an absolutely great NFL draft - the Bengals are poised to challenge the Ravens for the division (sorry Steelers).  I love Jermain Gresham and I love taking Carlos Dunlap to bring pressure on the opposing QBs.  I hope Carson Palmer can take the next step and become the elite QB he is supposed to be.


    QB:  Matt Schaub
    LT:  Duane Brown
    Defensive:  Mario Williams, Amobi Okeye

    I don't think the Texans did enough to reach over the hump that is the Indi Colts.  Their draft and off season is nothing special.  They lost Dunta Robinson and made amends in the draft - but the big issues that remain consistent are RB, and a play making secondary player.  I do like taking Kareem Jackson in the first round - this fills a need and adds depth.  I love Dorin Dickerson pick - he is a very special player.  I don't know Ben Tate well but I believe he should be a solid fit in the zone blocking system.  Although the off season was not negative - I do not think the Texans have done enough to make them that much better on offense and defense to be able to overcome the domination by the Colts the past few years. 


    Perry Fewel (DC)
    QB:  Eli Manning
    LT:  David Diehl
    Defense:  Justin Tuck, JPP, Antre Roll

    I absolutely love Perry Fewel with the Giants.  He has the players that will help thrive in his system.  I love the Giants picking JPP.  Although the Cowboys think they will run away with the division, and the Eagles have overcome the McNabb hump - I think the Giants have a shot at winning the division.  The Giants first three picks are fantastic.  JPP will bring the pressure, Joseph will stop the run, and Chad Jones is a young version of Rolle.


    Coaching:  Dick LeBeau (DC)
    QB:  Ben Rothlisberger
    LT:  Max Stark
    Defensive:  James Harrison, Troy Polamalou

    Lets us not concentrate too heavily on the losses the Steelers have faced on offense.  What defines the Pittsburgh Steeler franchise?  Hard nose defense, and running the ball.  Look for them to go back to that this season.  None the less - Their wide receiver depth is very weak unless Sweed surprises.  The defense is still strong.  I Love the first round pick - Pouncey will be great.  Even with Ben's issues the Steelers will succeed by going back to their roots.  I love Dwyer in the 6th round.

    QB:  Vince Young
    LT:  Michael Roos
    Defensive:  Weatherspoon

    The Titans had a good draft - but not great.  I love Derrick Morgan in the 1st and I love Myron Rolle in the later rounds.  I especially love the addition of Blount and Johnson as undrafted free agents.  Damian Williams is a solid fit in the second round.  Are the Titans better than last year?  Chris Johnson is whining about a new contract.  Yes the Titans are better.  Vince Young has matured significantly.  Morgan will make an instant impact.  But are they better than the Texans and the Colts?  I don't think so. 


    Coaches:  Sean McDermott (DC), Dick Jauron (DB), Bobby April (ST)
    QB:  Kevin Kolb
    LT:  Jason Peters
    Defensive:  Asante Samuel

    I love what the Eagles did this off season.  I love McNabb but it was about time to move on.  I think Kevin Kolb is a better pocket quarterback, and may at the end of the day be the better QB.  The biggest weakness is Andy Reids play calling in the playoffs.  His decision to pass every other play really cost the Eagles dearly.  I like the draft.  Graham is going to be a star.  I love Nate Allen at FS.  I love Jauron as the defensive backs coach and i love Bobby April as their special teams coach.  The offensive line needs to improve - but most importantly the Eagles running game needs to improve.  How do you survive life after Westbrook?

    QB:  Matt Ryan
    LT:  Sam Baker
    Defense:  John Abraham

    I love Matt Ryan.  He does a great job of pretending to be Peyton Manning.  He studies his tapes extensively.  He is going to be a superstar.  I love what Mike Smith has done with this team.  They will be back to contend next year especially with a healthy Michael Turner back.  I don't think the Falcons had a super draft.  I love the Weatherspoon pick - who will instantly start.  I also love the Dranks pick - late in the draft.  Corey Peters was taken too early.  Mike Johnson is also a great pick but they needed to address their DE needs.  The other picks are also questionable.  Signing Robinson was a great idea.


    oaching:  Mike Nolan (DC)
    QB:  Chad Henne
    LT:  Jake Long
    Defense:  Karlos Dansby

    The Dolphins made a very smart decision signing Mike Nolan as defensive coordinator which will significantly improve the defense.  The Dolphins lost a lot of veterans but this does not necessarily mean that the team went down hill.  Chad Henne is the future the franchise, and he has a fantastic LT to protect his blindside.  I like the Karlos Dansby pick up.  I think the Dolphins had an absolutely awesome drat.  Jared Odrick will be a superstar. 


    Coaching:  Mike Shanahan (HC)
    QB:  Donovan McNabb
    LT:  Trent Williams
    Defense:  London Fletcher, Hansworth
    The Redskins did not have a coach to bring out all the talent potential on this team.  I love Mike Shanahan as the coach and he will bring out the full potential of all the players (except a certain DT).  I love McNabb as their QB - he will have a host of young weapons to throw to.  Skins had an OK draft. 


    QB:  Matt Moore, Jimmy Clausen
    LT:  Jordan Gross
    Defense:  John Beason

    Love the Clausen pick.  Love the overall draft.  Panthers are a team i can't really figure out.  They have potential - lets see if they ever live up to it.  Clausen could start.


    QB:  David Garrard
    Eugene Monroe
    Defense:  Aaron Kapman

    Worst draft.  Um.  Not really sure what Jacksonville is thinking.  Still have a reasonable roster though....


    Kyle Ortan
    LT:  Ryan Clady
    Defensive:  Elvis Dummervil

    I think the Broncos took too much to take Tebow - but i LOVE the pick.  I can't wait to see what Josh McDaniels will do with Tebow in the offense - remember he coached Tom Brady when he broke the TD record.  The Defense lost big time when it lost Nolan.  McDaniel's shows the NFl what he has as an NFL coach this season. 


    QB:  Alex Smith
    LT:  Anthony Davis, Joe Staley
    Defensive:  Patrick Willis, TKO Spikes

    The 49ers will not be at this spot four weeks into the season.  I absolutely love what the niners did in the first round.  In fact I love the entire draft.  I love Singletary as the coach and I think Alex Smith will shed their stereotype as a draft bust.  The 49ers will win the division and quickly move up this list. 


    QB:  Matt Leinhart
    LT:  Levi Brown
    Defensive:  Dan Williams, Joey Porter, Cromartie

    The Cardinals have taken a step back after the retirement of Kurt Warner.  The tape that I have seen of Matt has not impressed me.  Karlos Dansby was lost in free agency and Boldin in a trade.  The first round pick was fantastic - Dan Williams is a stud NT and will help solidify the run support.  LT is questionable.  Matt's era is about to begin - lets see how he handles being a celebrity vs. being a football player.


    Coaches:  Mike Martz (OC)
    QB:  Jay Cutler
    LT:  Chris Williams
    Defensive:  Julius Pepper, Lance Briggs

    I firmly believe the Bears will make significant improvements, and Jay Cutler will improve under the coaching of Mike Martz.  I love the Pepper's signing - he is a perfect fit for the defense.  I love the first two draft picks - but question why on earth the Bears would take a QB?  Do they not believe in Cutler?  They could have gotten him another wide receiver as the WR depth is questionable.  The season rides on Cutler's development.

    Coaches:  Jim Schwartz
    QB:  Matt Stafford
    LT:  Jeff Backus
    Defensive:  Kyle Van Dan Bosch, Suh

    I absolutely love what Jim Schwartz has done with this team.  Regardless of opinion, I do believe Matthew Stafford is a franchise QB.  He does not remind me of JP Losman.  I like his toughness, arm strength, and swagger.  He reminds me more of Jay Cutler.  I love the rebuilding of the defense.  The Lions are slowly but surely building their franchise.  They will make significant strides this season.  Suh was a fantastic pick and I am glad that the Lions took.  Jim is very confident in Backus.  I think the Lions had a great draft.  I love Jahvid Best, and Jason Fox could be a 4th round sleeper.


    QB:  Jason Campbell
    LT:  Mario Henderson, Bruce Campbell, Jason Veldheer??
    Defensive:  Richard Seymour, Rolondo McClain, Asomugha

    I love what the Raiders did this offseason.  Quite frankly they might have had the best off season of any team because they changed their franchise philosophy.  Thank God they got rid of Jamarcus Garbage.  I like keeping Tom Gable as coach.  I LOVE their draft.  Not only did they pick up best available players - but Al Davis got his favorite prospect in the FOURTH ROUND - Bruce Campbell.  The team already has a fantastic defense - and I believe the offense will improve significantly with change in QB.  The running game will continue to flourish under McFadden and Bush. 


    QB:  Josh Freeman
    LT:  Donald Penn
    Defensive:  Gerald McCoy, Ronde Barber

    Two defensive tackles in a row?  What about other needs?  I do love both players though.  Tampa Bay Bay has a young team that will improve this season.  I love Freeman.  I don't like Penn. 


    Coaches:  Charlie Weiss (OC) Romeo Crennell (DC)
    QB:  Matt Cassel
    LT:  Brandon Albert
    Defensive:  Eric Berry, Mike Vrabel

    Ladies and Gentleman - Meet Patriots PT 2.  I don't like their draft - I think they should have drafted a LT and or NT - but Mr Scott Pioli knows far more than I do, and I think he knows exactly what he is doing.  I love hiring Weiss and Crenell.  Another great example of how to rebuild a team.  Chiefs will make strides this season. 


    Coaches:  Pete Carrol
    QB:  Matt Hasselback
    LT:  Russel Okung
    Defensive:  Aaron Curry, Latufu,

    Did anyone have a better draft than the Seahawks?  I absolutely love what Pete Carrol has done with this team.  It is very early but Carrol is on the right track.  He had a great draft, great off season - he picked up his old buddy lendale white but when he realized he had issues - released him.  The Seahawks are giving him total control of the organization - which is exactly what made him successful in USC.  Lets see if he can duplicate his success in the NFL.


    QB:  Jake Delhomme
    LT:  Joe Thomas
    Defensive:  Joe Haden, Fujita

    I like the fact that the Browns kept Mangini.  I think Mangini is a good coach.  I also like the Delhomme trade - although he is being paid more than he should but its good to have a veteran, once superbowl playing QB.  I love the Joe Hadden pick, and I love Hardessy at running back.  Eventually the Browns will find their franchise QB - next year perhaps.  I love Joe Thomas at LT.


    QB:  Trent Edwards
    LT:  ???
    Defensive:  Jarius Byrd, Aaron Schobel, Poz

    I love the Bills Draft.  I love CJ Spiller as the first round pick.  But at the same time I hate the draft because so much of the teams needs were completely ignored in the early rounds.  Not only the early rounds but nothing special was done in the off season.  The Bills are a team in the rebuilding process.  This year's draft had such a strong pool of talent at offensive tackle and defensive tackle.  As much as I love Trent Edwards - he is not the answer for the franchise.  I love the running game of this team but who blocks?  He protects Trent Edwards blind side?  Who plays along side Lee Evans to take some pressure of him?  What about the defense?  We have many strong playmakers but Schobel is questioning retirement.  Our nose tackle is Kyle Williams and Torrel Troup - Troup was taken of Joseph.......Even if Clausen is not better than Trent Edwards in the eyes of our front office.....he was available in the second round.  McCoy was available going into the third round.  I am so incredible confused.  While all the teams in the AFC East are getting better - we are not holding up.......  I love the way the Detroit Lions have quickly and in a high quality manner rebuilt their team.  I am such a hardcore Bills fan - but when I made these rankings I wanted to be realistic.  Not pessimistic, not optimistic - Realistic.

    I have been thoroughly ripped apart for putting the Bills so low.  So Let us analyze.  The Buffalo Bills have completely turned around their philosophy from last year.  Not only did they fire practically every coach at every significant position - they switched from a Tampa 2 4-3 defense to a two gap 3-4 defense.  They are practically completely opposite defenses. One defense focuses on smaller faster players while the other defense focuses on large gap controlling defensive lineman.  The offense is completely changing.  Last season we saw a OC fire, a QB coach fired, a HC fired, and a DC take over offensive calling duties.  Hurricane?  Furthermore Trent Edwards and Ryan Fitzpatrick circled the wagon at QB.  TOI has left the team and so has Josh Reed.  Who do the QB's throw to when Lee Evans is double covered?  Who is the left tackle?  Who will protect those QBs?  The team is at step one.  IT needs to first completely changed philosophy than find the appropriate players to fit those holes.  I'm sorry to those who disagree.  But the fact is the Bills are starting from STEP ONE - blue prints and have a long way to go.  The team has a lot of maturing to do.


    QB:  Sam Bradford
    LT:  Jason Smith
    Defensive:  Chris Long, James Laurintus

    I love Sam Bradford.  I think he is a franchise QB and I think the Rams will not be the worst team in the NFL as the season begins.  But Bradford has a long way to go and a lot of learning to do.  Rams will still have a top 5 pick next year.

Just another great fan opinion shared on the pages of

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Buffalo Rumblings

You must be a member of Buffalo Rumblings to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Buffalo Rumblings. You should read them.

Join Buffalo Rumblings

You must be a member of Buffalo Rumblings to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Buffalo Rumblings. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.