With the way the Bills are playing, Dump is a very apt title

- Is baseball still being played? I haven’t cared less about baseball in a long time. It isn’t even because my team stinks, they have stunk many times before and I have still cared. I simply have zero desire to watch any baseball what-so-ever.

Hold on Eric, just 1 more month before the NHL is back, then we can start arguing over who is the best team again, your Rangers or my Habs.

Never played for Andy Reid before, I honestly believe that Andy Reid can win with any QB, we could trade Trent Edwards for Michael Vick styraight up and Philly would come out on top of the deal becuase thats how QB friendly Phillies offense is.

He has been for going on 4-5 years now. It’s laughable to consider him a top WR. He’s a good deep threat, which may not even be the case any more, but hardly better than average anywhere else. $8-9M a year for that is pretty funny.

Totally agree on the Vick hyperbole in the media…it’s out of control. As far as Evans goes, I totally blame the QB for his stalled career. He has talent and he has produced in the past. I think Edwards destroys everything he comes in contact with and we won’t truly appreciate how bad he was until we’re a few years removed from him. Evans is the first WR who couldn’t produce consistently because he has a sub-CFL talent pitching him the ball.

Though i agree that he is vastly overrated…..When he was in Atlanta he didnt have the weapons he could have if given the philly job. His best player in Atl was Alge Crumpler. Roddy White was very green and not the reciever he is now. But with Jackson, Maclin, Celek and McCoy i would venture to say that maybe even Trent would be an acceptable option at QB.

I completely agree on Spiller.

I think Lee Evans is a pretty darn good WR. I’ve criticized him in the past, but mostly only when people try to say he’s a top 10 WR stuck in a bad situation. I think Evans is an elite deep threat and that ability opens up the sidelines for him to find success on outs and digs. There’s a reason why multiple offensive coordinators have kept him over by the sideline.

Whether or not Evans is a number one WR depends on your definition. The comparison I use is an ace in baseball (see how I worked in baseball since you mentioned it?). Is a pitcher an ace because he’s a stopper in the rotation or because he’s simply the best pitcher on his team and one of the 32 best in the league? Lee Evans isn’t a true number one WR. I don’t think it’s tough to come to that conclusion considering that his game is kind of limited. I think he’s definitely one of the 32 best WRs in the league though, so he’s kind of a number one in that regard. It’s not just in Buffalo that Evans would be the number one guy.

Another way to look at that might include pass catching TEs though. Even adding the elite weapons at the position could push Evans out of the top 32 receivers in the NFL. If I were listing them, he still might sneak in though.

I agree on Vick as well. But in the same way that Evans could be considered a number one WR, I think Vick is a starter. I think Vick will be starting for somebody next year because he should be starting. The rest of his career will be that of a stop gap though. He’ll bounce from team to team starting a year or two then getting relegated to the bench when some young QB is ready to take over. If the Bills were to draft a mobile QB this year, they could do a lot worse than Vick as a stop gap. I’d prefer my team go nowhere near him and his unthinkable crimes though.