Bills 2010 Film Review: Confirming Suspicions, Week 7
Now that we've broken down the Buffalo Bills' Week 7 loss to the Baltimore Ravens last season, we'll wrap that game up in a nice little bow by re-examining some of the post-game rhetoric following that devastating loss. We'll start with the immediate post-game discussion, then move on to breakdowns offered here by Der Jaeger and Ron From NM.
Post-game: Coming off a bye week, and having watched the Bills roll over and die in two (arguably three) of their first five games, a lot of the focus in this post-game was on the positives. We were desperate for some happy thoughts. Most of the focus was on the outstanding statistical production of Ryan Fitzpatrick, Lee Evans and Stevie Johnson. Fitzpatrick's 373 yards ended a 56-game streak of Bills quarterbacks that hadn't thrown for 300 yards in a game.
I did take the time to touch on some of Buffalo's mistakes - and mistakes were what killed Buffalo, as they simply out-played (and out-coached, by the way) a better team. In the post-game thread, however, I stated my belief that Shawn Nelson's forward progress had been stopped on the overtime fumble. I'll rescind that statement. I think the refs made the right call.
Der Jaeger's good and bad: DJ nailed the bad, citing the team's inability to set the edge against the run and their inability to cover tight ends as major problems. Once again, misdirection plays killed the Bills in this one; Buffalo's defenders tended to bite hard on any run action in the two games we've reviewed so far. DJ's third bad item, however, seems a bit of a reach in retrospect, particularly in relation to Roscoe Parrish, who was outstanding in this game. Regarding Spiller, however, his point is very valid.
On the positive side, DJ threw "sure, the Ravens' corners are weak" into his analysis almost as an aside, but it can be argued that they were largely responsible for Buffalo's outstanding passing attack. I can't undersell just how awful they were. Chan Gailey also earns praise for his offensive play-calling, which was well-deserved, but some questionable decisions - particularly a decision to pass up a tying field goal attempt for a bad fourth-and-one play that didn't convert - weren't mentioned. Coordinator Gailey was great, but head coach Gailey was somewhat questionable, in my opinion.
Ron's O-Line notes: The folks at Pro Football Focus were not impressed with Cordaro Howard, who started and played every snap at right tackle, in this game. Ron was slightly more impressed, if only because he was not a significant downgrade to the man he replaced, Cornell Green. In re-watching, I'm with PFF - Howard really struggled, particularly in the second half (though Gailey tried to excuse that somewhat to fatigue, apparently). I also didn't see what Ron saw in terms of Andy Levitre and Geoff Hangartner in pass protection. I thought Levitre was significantly better than Hangartner in that contest.
6 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
You rewatched this, I didn't
I recall Nelson being elevated and being moved with the other players pushing/ pulling him either forward/backwards where ever. At some point isn’t that considered being down. He was elevated for about a full second or two an Lewis just ripped the ball out. It was either give up the ball or his left arm. You revisited this, I am probably over exaggerating a bit, but convince me again that this was the right call.
YOU ARE OUT of you kuku fufu mine craker laker Flaber baber FUNKI chunki brain. WE want to winn every year -- abayarde
Why would he be considered down?
He was moving forward when the ball was ripped out. His movement never stopped and he wasn’t being pushed backwards at all. Video from NFL.com
You see players being pushed forward by teammates all the time, especially near the goal line. The situation was similar here, only Nelson couldn’t hang onto the ball….
~K
"As the governor of Louisiana once said, the only way Chris Kelsay can lose his job is if he got caught in bed with a dead girl or a live boy."
I remember that play so differently.
This does clear it up, Nelson took some shots, bet he had some headaches soon after. My original thinking was be cause he was elevated and not progressing or regressing on his own power would be considered down by contact.
YOU ARE OUT of you kuku fufu mine craker laker Flaber baber FUNKI chunki brain. WE want to winn every year -- abayarde
I remember when Chan covered this in the post game interview
The ref explained to him that they were forced to rule the play as a fumble since the whole pile was still moving forward. The zebras were prepared to give him all the inches the Bills were “gaining” in this scrum. I also remember how that play made me sick, and that explanation made me angry as Nelsoon literally could not go to the ground if he was on fire. After my feelings stopped hurting I too realized this was the right call.
The AFC East is, perhaps, the league's most talented division, making it the most respectable division to finish last in. -The Onion
by JonasPounder on May 28, 2011 2:37 PM EDT up reply actions
IF the unthinkable happens
and the lockout continues into August, any chance we can get you to review one game from 2010 per week or something? This is easily my favorite series of the offseason (not that I don’t enjoy the other ones)
by Denver's Buffalo Fan on May 28, 2011 10:54 AM EDT reply actions
I will have to go watch it again my self but from what i remember. His feet where up off the ground clearly visible to everyone. His forward progress was kept up from ravens players pulling him along no one was pushing on that team. He was going to stay up in the air until the ball came out. I know that theres people pushing all the time on goal lines but most of the time the running backs feet or qbs feet are on the ground. so i think this one should of been called as a stop of forward progress. No offesne brian but i dnt trust your judgement or the refs on this one. I am more of chans mind set wtf no one is pushing him and he is being lifted and pulled along. Least now gailey shld have a defense trick. put the guy on you shoulders and dnt put him down till he agreaas to drop the ball. same basic concept right as long as you walk forward the play has to contiune.
"This is a chance to shine some light on the city, They say it’s too cold. I’m going to bring some warmth to it." Marcell Dareus
by matthew62 on May 28, 2011 9:21 PM EDT via mobile reply actions

by 






























