Mock Buffalo Bills Offseason

Greetings Bills fan,

I am a Panthers fan who recently participated in a mock offseason over on Cat Scratch Reader, the Carolina Panthers SB Nation page. The idea was that 32 people would take control of a NFL franchise through free agency, the draft, and trades. I obviously volunteered to lead a makeover of the Buffalo Bills. I chose the Bills for what should become an obvious reasoning once looking through my draft. Living in the Carolinas, I grew up as a big Clemson University fan and C.J. Spiller was my favorite player when he went through Clemson. So, I have decided to bring you what I have done to the Buffalo Bills to see what you think. Hopefully, most of you think I did a good job.

-Note- The base roster we started with was the Buffalo Bill's roster as in sometime in January, so some big moves are not included. Which includes the release of QB Ryan Fitzpatrick and WR David Nelson or the retiring of DE Chris Kelsay

Starting Philosophy

I started with the belief that the Buffalo Bills had a good roster just needed some polishing to make them into a contender. First thing I needed to solve was the QB issue. As you will see, I quickly took charge and added competition. Not the real sexy move, but I made a move for competition sake. I also took care of a certain player with a big contract who isn't performing well. I also wanted to build through the draft and through trades ended up with 12 draft picks. In the Free agency I collected as many players I could to create even more competition. So without further ado I will show you the trades that started off the whole ordeal.


The rules were that each GM could only use 3 trades, but was amended later to included 2 draft day trades. I only used two of the original trades but did use both of the draft day trades.

-Original Trades

- Traded DE Mario Williams to the Chicago Bears for their 4th and 5th round draft picks
The idea here was just to offload the underachieving player who I believed was just never going to fit
in with this team and play up to his pay level. I could have gotten more, however, I still believe I got value with this trade

-Traded Chicago's 4th round draft pick to the Dallas Cowboys for QB Kyle Orton
Honestly, I think I messed up with this one. I could have gotten QB Alex Smith for the same price but I didn't think a 4th round pick was worth it, but I realized once I had the Orton trade in my lap that a 4th round pick was about right. I added competition for Fitzpatrick and maybe this pushes Fitz or Orton to the next level, who knows. I am following the Pete Carroll's strategy with finding a franchise Quarterback.

-Draft Day Trades

-Traded 2nd round draft pick to The Seattle Seahawks for their late 2nd, two 4ths, a 5th and 7th round draft picks
This where I started to horde draft picks. I don't think I missed out on any prospects I wanted by moving to the tail end of the 2nd round. I think I hit a home run with this trade.

-Traded 3rd round draft pick to the Houston Texans for their 3rd and 6th round draft picks
Honestly, this trade was done just because. While the Texans made the move to secure their prospect, I did it to... well to get even more draft picks.

Free Agency

The rules with free agency was that each team had $25 to spend no matter what the real life team had in their cap space. Also we had a bid style of free agency where whoever had the highest bid after 48 hours of the last bid, won the player. The top 5 free agents as indicated on Walter Football were the only players to enter free agency.

Players won in Free Agency

-S Jarius Byrd (Franchised tagged for $6)
-This was a no-brainer. This move had to be made to secure the future at safety. Be rest assured that had Byrd reached free agency he we would have gone for much higher than $6 in our crazy free agency.

- G Chad Rhinehart ($4)
- Had to win Rhinehart after losing Levitire. This move helps keep stability at the guard position.

-TE Brandon Myers ($3)
-After striking out on several other TE prospects, I finally landed this TE. I believe he is a nice backup and adds some depth under Scott Chandler

- OLB Justin Durant ($3)
-So after looking through the Bills roster it became apparent that they needed LB help in the worse way. This addition help with that issue and builds depth.

-OLB Larry Grant ($2)
-Like I said, yall needed a bunch of LB help, so he is someone else who can come in and help.

-DE Junior Galette ($2)
-With the trade of DE Williams, the Bills were in large need of a DE and this helps out a bit.

-WR David Nelson ($1)
-While not the best WR, he adds depth and can surely help out with the future WR corps.

-P Donnie Jones ($1)
-Jones ends up not making the final roster due to a rookie Punter who out-shines Jones.

-KR Joshua Cribbs ($1)
- I decided to let Mckelvin walk in free agency, so I needed someone who could go compete with C.J. Spiller for the returner jobs.

Players Lost in Free Agency

-G Andy Levitre (won by the Rams for $10)
-Just could not afford him. Figured it was better to move on from him and use the depth we had to go forward at the guard position.

-CB/KR Leodis McKelvin (won by the Eagles for $3)
-Just too much money for a mediocre CB and KR.

The Draft

Now for my favorite part. Remember I had 12 draft picks, so I loaded up with talent here. So without further ado, here comes my draft picks

Draft Picks:

1st/8th DeMarcus Milner, CB, Alabama
-This pick fell right into my lap. Geno Smith went right before this pick, but I never planned to pick a QB this early. Milner allows us to have two good CBs who can lock down almost any WR tandem.
2nd/24th(56th) Justin Hunter, WR, Tennesse
-Other than Jonhson, there was nothing at the WR position. Going after Hunter allowed us to have more weapons here. Honestly, I wanted Hopkins, but he was gone even before my original 2nd round pick. However, Hunter is a great pick-up;
3rd/12th(74th) Ryan Nassib, QB, Syracuse
-Head Coach Doug Marrone wants his own QB, and believes his former college QB has want it takes. Plus Nassib already knows Marrone's system, so we would come in and help others to adjust.This pick allows more competition for Orton and Fitz. This is a great value pick, though he did go before Barkley, which went in the 4th round.
4th/8th(104th) Andre Ellington, RB, Clemson
-This was my first Clemson homer pick. Now we have a Clemson tandem and RB. Ellington should work out well as the backup to Spiller. Got home just in time to make this pick. Almost missed out.
4th/16th(112th) Ricky Wagner, OT, Wisconsin
-Wagner projects as the future at LT. This pick works out well.
4th/24th(120th) Xavier Nixon, OT, Florida
-So I lucked out that Nixon projects as a RT. I didn't really do much research before this pick, but I am glad I ended up not selecting two RTs or two LTs. Nixon is the future at RT.
5th/10th(138th) Vince Williams, MLB, Florida State
-Needing more LB help, Williams comes in and competes for the starter job on day one. He seems to be the future LB we need.
5th/20th(148th) Malicah Goodman,DE, Clemson
- What? I had to add more Clemson depth to this team. Goodman allows more depth at DE after the Williams trade.
5th/25th(153th) B.W. Webb,CB, William & Mary
-Needed more CB depth and I believe Webb allows us to make up for not bringing back McKelvin.
6th/9th Dalton Freeman, C, Clemson
-Yes, another Clemson Tiger. I had to do it. This guy is a beast and will push Wood from day one.
6th/27th Brad Wing, P, LSU
-This was a spur of the moment pick. Wing works out well at being the future at Punter for this team.
7th/14th Marcus Sales, WR, Syracuse
-I wanted the other Syracuse WR in Lemon, however, this pick also works. Sales will help Nassib with the transition into the NFL.

The Cuts

So before we get to my final 53 roster, I have included the players I have cut from the team. Maybe some of the cuts are big cuts, but I don't think they are.

-Final Cuts(28)
-QB: Tyler Thigpen, Tarvaris Jackson
I decided to keep Fitzpatrick for time being. Jackson was the easy cut, just doesn't fit with our scheme. Ironically, I have been a big Clemson homer through this mock offseason, but Thigpen is from the town I currently live in, but I end up cutting him.
-RB: Fred Jackson
It was time to get rid of the 32 year old RB. While he did have his good years at Buffalo, it was time for a new backup behind C.J. Spiller.
-FB: Dorin Dickerson
-While he is the equivalent of the Panther's Richie Brockel as the versatile TE/FB, we just did not have the room for him on the roster.
-WR: Brad Smith, Ruvell Martin, Kevin Elliot, Chris Hogan
These were all roster filler, so these were easy releases.
-TE: Mike Caussin
-Had to make room for Brandon Myers, so this was an easy decision
-LT: Chris Hairston, Thomas Welch
More easy releases, just had to make room on the roster
-C: Colin Brown
No longer needed him as backup because I drafted Freeman.
-RT: Sam Young, Chris Scott
Easy releases. Just needed more room for drafted players.
-LE: Spencer Johnson
What can I say? Just another depth player needed to go to make room for more depth
-DT: Jarron Gilbert, Jay Ross
This was a position I did not need to do anything to, but cut the fat.
-RE: Chris Kelsay, Kyle Moore
So Kelsay doesn't retire, but I cut him instead.
-LOLB: Nigel Bradham, Chris White, Greg Lloyd
Just more fat being cut.
-MLB: Kirk Morrison
-This made room for draft pick Vince Williams to make the cut.
-ROLB: Byran Scott
So the player who is staying with the real life Bills, I cut, go figure.
-CB: Crezdon Butler, T.J. Heath
Had to make room for Milner and Webb.
-P: Shawn Powell, Donnie Jones
-There goes the old starter and the FA punter.

Finally The Final Roster

So this mock offseason ends with the naming of the final 53 guys that make the roster. I believe that the 2013 Mock Buffalo Bills will field a very good team this season.

Notes: Bold indicates Starter, Italics indicates draft picks, * indicates trade, ^ indicates Free Agency pick-up

-QB: Ryan Fitzpatrick, Ryan Nassib, Kyle Orton*
-Fitzpatrick remains the starter while Nassib pushes him. Its possible Nassib shines in training camp and wins the starter job, similar to Russel Wilson in Seattle in 2012. Orton is the veteran backup who also is in the mix for the starting job.
-HB: C.J Spiller, Andre Ellington, Tashard Choice
-Briefly thought about retaining Jackson as the #3 RB, however, decided it was just better to cut ties and have Choice remain as the 3rd option. Spiller finally takes over as the #1 and Ellington is in as the backup.
-FB: Corey McIntyre
-Simple move here for McIntrye to remain as the starter and only FB.
-#1WR: Stevie Johnson, Marcus Sales
-Stevie remains the obvious #1 and Sales makes the roster and his the backup for Johnson
-#2WR: Justin Hunter, Donald Jones
-Our 2nd round draft pick makes the roster as the #2. And Jones stays on the roster as Hunter's backup.
-#3WR: David Nelson, Joshua Cribbs^
-Nelson wins out as the #3 WR with Cribbs or Sales pushing him.
-TE: Scott Chandler, Brandon Myers, Lee Smith
-Finally added depth under Chandler with Myers. Smith stays on the roster as the 3rd option.
-LT: Cordy Glenn, Xavier Nixon
After rethinking this, Moving Glenn to G and having Nixon start at LT seems the better move.
-LG: Chad Rhinehart, Keith Williams
-The ultimate backup now moves to a starter position. Should look at upgrading in the future.
-C: Eric Wood, Dalton Freeman
We now have a real backup and future at center in Freeman.
-RG: Kraig Urbik, David Snow
- Urbik makes the move to starter and Snow is moving from C to backup RG.
-RT: Erik Pears, Ricky Wagner
Wagner will surely push Pears through training camp and may be the day one starter at RT.

-LE: Shawne Merriman, Mallicah Goodman
-Merriman takes over for Mario Williams, doesn't impress but is a solid starter. Mallicah will be a great backup.
-DT: Kyle Williams, Marcell Dareus, Torrell Troup, Corbin Bryant
-Nothing to be done here, great players here.
-RE: Mark Anderson, Junior Galette^
-Anderson remains the answer at RE, but Galette is there if Anderson can't get the job done.
-LOLB: Justin Durant^, Arthur Moats
-Durant is now the starter and will be an upgrade over Moats.
-MLB: Kelvin Sheppard, Vince Williams
-Sheppard stays as the starter at MLB, but Vince Williams has what it takes to make the move to starter if need be.
-ROLB: Nick Barnett, Larry Grant^
-The Mock Bills do not release Barnett, but do add Grant to push him.
- #1CB: DeMarcus Milner*, Terrence Mcgee, Aaron Williams
-The 8th draft pick in the draft is set to start from day one. Mcgee and Williams gives us great depth.
- #2CB: Stephon Gilmore, Justin Rogers, Ron Brooks
-This had to be done. As a Clemson fan, I could not have a USC Gamecock as the #1 CB.But Gilmore will surely be a great #2 CB.
-FS: Jarius Byrd, Mana Silva
-Thankfully, I tagged Byrd and he will remain the future at the safety position.
-SS: George Wilson, Da’Norris Searcy
-No change here was needed.

-Special Teams
-K: Rian Lindell
-Was looking to upgrade at kicker through draft, but did not work out, so Lindell is still the starter
-P: Brad Wing
-I wanted a new kicker, but got a new punter instead.
-LS: Garrison Sanborn
-I am in favor of dropping the LS position and just have a o-lineman already on the roster to do the job. But since the real Bills believe a real LS is needed, I kept Sanborn on the roster.
-KR/PR: C.J. Spiller, Joshua Cribbs
-Spiller will be the starter at both position, but Cribbs will fill in when needed.

Here are the links to all of the Mock off season articles over at CSR if you want to view the whole thing.

First Article
Transaction Thread
Free Agency Thread
Free Agency Discussion Thread
Pre draft Thread
First Day Chat Thread
First Day Chat Thread #2
First Round Thread
Second Round Thread
Third Round Thread
Second Day Thread

Fourth Round Thread
Fifth Round Thread
6th Round Thread
Seventh Round Thread
UDFA Thread
Final 53 Man Roster

All Thanks goes to OldhamA who was the guy in charge. He surely did a good job keeping this a float.

What do yall think? Did I do a good job or a terrible job? What would you have done differently? And does this roster give the Bills a chance to overtake the hated Patriots?

Thanks for looking this over and giving me your input.

Just another great fan opinion shared on the pages of

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Buffalo Rumblings

You must be a member of Buffalo Rumblings to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Buffalo Rumblings. You should read them.

Join Buffalo Rumblings

You must be a member of Buffalo Rumblings to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Buffalo Rumblings. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.