Bills May Look to Add Return Threat in Draft
![]() |
|
|
Ever since special teams coordinator Bobby April joined the Buffalo Bills' coaching staff in 2004, the Bills' special teams unit have been among the most dominant units in the league. Part of the reason for their success has been the fact that two of the unit's stars, kick returner Terrence McGee and punt returner Roscoe Parrish, rank among the league's elite in what they do.
However, that may change during the 2008 season, at least from the kick return standpoint. McGee, who will turn 28 during the '08 season, has been a starting cornerback and the full-time kick returner for the past three seasons. That type of work load will be difficult to McGee to shoulder, especially as Buffalo's coaching staff continues to rely on him to improve as a defender. Heading into the 2008 draft, it is imperative for the Bills to find a kick return threat that can replace McGee as the "starter" and allow the veteran corner to focus on defense. It is still possible that McGee would be asked to return kicks in critical situations, but it's clear by McGee's declining kick return average (he only averaged 24 yards per return last year) that his workload must be reduced.
So who could Buffalo add to help in this department? Below, we've listed seven draft prospects that have a realistic shot at being drafted by the Bills and have a great chance to be excellent return specialists at the NFL level. (Note: two of the draft's elite return threats, Arkansas RB Felix Jones and East Carolina's Chris Johnson, are excluded from this list because the Bills won't be drafting a RB early enough to land one of them.)
Troy CB Leodis McKelvin - widely regarded as the top cornerback prospect in this year's draft, McKelvin is probably the most explosive return threat available this year outside of the Jones/Johnson combo at running back. Buffalo would need to acquire him at pick 11 to get him, but he could play a role similar to what McGee played early in his career - sub-package corner and starting kick returner.
Michigan State WR Devin Thomas - arguably the best receiver available this season, Thomas averaged over 30 yards per return last season at Michigan State, a year in which he amassed over 2,500 all-purpose yards. He has the type of acceleration and open-field ability that all the great return threats have. Buffalo would need to nab him in the first, and he may end up a starting receiver here, so asking him to pull double duty as a rookie could be a stretch.
Penn State CB Justin King - no, King did not return kicks in college very often. However, the underrated corner prospect has freakish athletic ability (he ran a 4.31 40) and with a little coaching could be one of the best return threats in the league. King is a second-round prospect that could fit into a Cover 2 defense, so he's an intriguing early-round option for Buffalo.
Virginia Tech WR Eddie Royal - Buffalo needs to draft a receiver, but Royal may not fit the bill. Royal has great speed, but is only 5'10", so the Bills may view him as a bit too small to draft. However, Royal comes from a VT program that prides itself on playing great special teams, and his 4.39 speed would make him a solid return threat as a rookie.
Connecticut CB Tyvon Branch - Branch is probably my favorite prospect in this year's draft when it comes to kick returns. Branch pumped a 4.31-second 40 at the Combine, and his corner skills are perfectly suited for a Cover 2 defense. He's an excellent athlete and a team leader, and he provided UConn many short fields with his kick return abilities. He'd be a fantastic addition for the Bills, possibly as early as the second round.
West Virginia RB Steve Slaton - one of the most productive running backs to ever play college football, Slaton's draft stock is sliding due to poor measurables at the NFL level. After scoring 50 career rushing touchdowns at WVU, Slaton is looking at a third down back/return role in the NFL. He has some wear on his tires, but not enough to realize that he would be a fantastic complement to Marshawn Lynch in the backfield and one of the best return threats in the NFL. Plus, he may only require a fifth-round pick to draft.
LA-Monroe RB Calvin Dawson - Dawson is a small-school, late-round draft prospect that has "third down back" written all over him. However, he has the necessary speed and shiftiness to be a solid return man, and he could develop into a nice complement to Buffalo's physical-oriented RB trio of Lynch, Fred Jackson and Dwayne Wright. He'd be a nice bargain draft prospect for the Bills to use one of their three seventh-round picks on.
0 recs |
30 comments
Comments
Why is McGee done?
I would imagine either McKelvin or Thomas, if drafted, would have the same issues of divided attention. Both those players would be asked to make large contributions on their side of the ball. If we do draft either, I say put them out there at the same time as McGee to limit the other team's options on where to kick. Kicking squib kicks and kicking short to, or away from McGee, were a big reason his numbers dropped off. Other teams starting treating him like the threat he is, and adjusted their kick-oo game plans accordingly. Maybe with another legitimate returner, instead of guys like the A-Train, we can get great field position more often.
My final argument with shelfing McGee on kick returns is: If you have a weapon, why not use it? He is a rare kick return talent with strength, speed, and the ability to change direction like very few players in the league. I know the point is to give him more focus on defense, but he's been so instrumental to our offense with field position we need him out there. Don't replace him, just put another talented player back there with him. Imagine him back there with someone like Devin Thomas. That's bad news for the other team.
by jj24 on Apr 6, 2008 9:39 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
There comes a point
As I said, let McGee handle return duties in crucial situations. Otherwise, what's the harm in finding another solid return threat to handle the normal duties? It's great for McGee and it's great for our special teams to have more than one threat.
As for your two-returner idea, it's not something that Bobby April has ever favored. He does it on punt returns, but only when Jim Leonhard - who plays a hitter's position - is the up returner, as he can still block to an extent. April would rather have a "fullback" back deep with one returner for blocking purposes; that's why you saw the likes of Anthony Thomas and London Fletcher back there in years past. It's a good idea to have two returners back there, but I don't think Bobby April prefers it.
by Brian Galliford on Apr 6, 2008 9:46 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Bobby April doesn't favor it
With other teams adjusting their kickoff strategy to concede to us starting at our own 30-35 yard line, maybe we should consider adjusting our strategies as well. Get another guy back there who WANTS to catch the ball instead of waiting for McGee to come over and get it. In other words, I hope April wouldn't be too stubborn to realize he needs to be open to change when our kick return is being gameplanned against.
by jj24 on Apr 6, 2008 10:05 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I think you're right
by Brian Galliford on Apr 6, 2008 10:10 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
returners
Isn't McKelvin more of a punt returner? I don't think he was ever an elite kick returner.
What about Keenan Burton? He's been a pretty good kick returner in the SEC for the past few seasons.
Chad Simpson is the late round RB I'd look at.
I don't think Slaton scored 70 TD's at WVU. I have him for 50.
I don't think McGee needs to be replaced. Instead we need a replacement in place in case he gets injured or becomes ineffective. He hasn't had trouble balancing his defensive role with his kick return duties in the past, so I don't see why'd he struggle with it this year. I do want him fresh for D, but I don't know that taking away return duties would change anything.
by Kurupt on Apr 6, 2008 10:00 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Re:
- McKelvin can return either punts or kicks, but yes, he had better success as a punt returner.
-Burton doesn't have game-breaking speed. He'd be a great depth receiver with star potential for us, but usually kick returners are smaller guys with good speed and power. Burton isn't that.
- Yes... You're right on Slaton's TD total. That was a typo. I'll be fixing that momentarily. :)
- Like I said, I don't think McGee needs to be replaced, either. But if we can cut his KR load in, say, half, it benefits us everywhere.
by Brian Galliford on Apr 6, 2008 10:08 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
WHEN is that?
I for one don't understand why Roscoe cannot return kicks. And the argument that he is too small makes no sense at all. How is returning a kick so much more punishing than a Punt? Same deal, you are returning a kick and guys are running full speed at you.
To sum up. Drafting a guy that could split time with McGee or eventually take the job over would be ideal, BUT I think that player would have to be a stud, cuz I think the world of McGee because he has great vision, uncanning ability to change direction, and the flat speed to go the distance.
by MARVelous on Apr 6, 2008 10:02 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
The time is now
Please understand the difference between "returning kicks" and "returning kicks full-time". McGee needs a break, and he isn't getting any younger. He's got a lot of wear on his tires already, and we need him to improve at cornerback. As I've said repeatedly, both in the article and in the comments section, McGee does NOT need to be fully replaced. Just complemented.
It's actually quite different. Watch Devin Hester return a kickoff as opposed to a punt, and you'll see what I mean. Punt returning is all about setting up your man, making the first guy (or two) miss, finding the angle and accelerating. Kick returning is all about following your wedge, making one cut and exploding. There's a lot more shiftiness needed for punt returns, which is why Parrish is excellent in that department. You need power, balance and tackle-breaking ability to bust through the wedge on kick returns, which is why Parrish isn't great returning kickoffs.
by Brian Galliford on Apr 6, 2008 10:15 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
KR vs. PR
Although the media will never let you notice, Devin Hester is actually an awful KR. He is certainly a homerun threat who can score any time he touches the ball, but statistically, he was one of the worst KRs in the whole league last season. Hester averaged only 21.7 yards per return last season. Of the 33 players who had 20 or more KRs Hester had the 3rd LOWEST average. His two scores were his only returns to go for more than 40 yards. He even fumbled the ball twice.
Not that I'll get any kind of argument here, but Parrish is a better punt returner than Hester as well. He averaged 16.3 yards per return compared to Hester's 15.5. Hester had 15 more returns, but only managed 2 more 20+ yard returns than Parrish did. Teams were actually more willing to kick to Hester than they were Parrish. Hester also fumbled a ridiculous 5 times. He is as likely to turn the ball over as he is to make sportscenter with a return.
by kaisertown on Apr 6, 2008 11:03 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
#KR's versus #PR's
Hopefully the improvement on offense (scoring touchdowns) and defense (stopping opposing offenses) will not only lead to more wins, but also help the special teams. In that case, maybe we'll see more punt returns (Parrish) than kick returns (McGee), anyway?
by Fort Worth on Apr 6, 2008 1:58 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
CB King
He was a receiver his freshman year and was as explosive as any I've seen in a while! His production dropped some when they moved him to corner but I point that to his lack of experience but he's still draftable...especially for his explosiveness and KR/PR possibilities!
I would use one of our 4th round draft picks on him or trade up into the 3rd to snatch him up...this would upgrade our special teams and he has the ability to play CB or WR!!!!
by Teaters33 on Apr 6, 2008 10:20 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I guess
Teams kick the ball away from McGee and spend there preparation specifically for McGee's abilities and the ST's unit as a whole. Is McGee going to explode if he keeps returning kicks? Is there an expiration date on him? I don't buy it.
As far as Parrish goes I see your logic and reasoning there.
by MARVelous on Apr 6, 2008 10:21 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Want to respond to one last point
Neither do I. But it's going to become more difficult for him to handle the older he gets, and he's already in his "prime". What is the harm of adding a McGee-like CB/KR hybrid, Tyvon Branch, and easing him into the exact same role that McGee held down when he was at his best returning kicks? (That would be 2005, when he was a nickel back and had three scores on returns.)
Again, this isn't entirely a question about McGee's abilities. It's about doing what's best for the team. If sacrificing some of McGee's kick returns makes him a better defender, but we still can use him on special teams, I don't understand how that's a bad move - especially if our rookie brings a little bit different return style to the table. That makes our special teams more dangerous as well.
by Brian Galliford on Apr 6, 2008 11:00 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
There are reasons
by Joe P. on Apr 6, 2008 7:48 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I agree completely Brian
Injury WILL strike McGee down either this season or the next on a ST teams play. Why?
1- Because of the amount of punishment he receives each time he takes the ball up field out of the end zone, it takes a toll, and playing D full time will not help at his age.
2- Other teams are gunning for him, and if anyone says otherwise, you've never played football at any level. When my teams played anyone, whether they were a good team or bad, if one of their more important, or best player was out on special teams, especially handling the ball, we went for the kill shot each and every time, no questions asked (And he is our STARTING CB, instant target). McGee has dodged a lot of those so far in his career, but someone is gonna nail him soon, the odds are just getting worse for him in that dept.
Do I think McGee will be better on D for less ST time in practice and games? He should be slightly to moderately better, but for me the issue is more keeping him on the field full time on D, our biggest area of need. STs right now is not as crucial to our getting over .500 as a solid D and a much improved offense is, and if we can get a later round wideout who can retunr kicks and challenge Roscoe and Reed for the slot job, I'm all in.
It really is a basic question that must be asked, do we get his eventual replacement this season and break them in; or take a risk some dude blows out one of McGee's knees or busts up one of his legs in a pile up durng a meaningless runback in a game alreayd decided? I want a new body out there so McGee has a better chance to stay on the field for us.
by WABillsfan on Apr 7, 2008 1:58 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Hurt on a return
McGee plays very hard on defense and supports the run a lot. He's more likely to get rolled up by a lineman while supporting the run or get hurt breaking up a pass with the wide receiver and secondary crowds. He could get a stinger or a bruised hip taking a shot from a RB running downhill on him, but I don't see returning kicks being more dangerous than playing defense.
by jj24 on Apr 7, 2008 8:16 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Well
I would say about 2 KRs get hurt every year. Thats mostly a guess, but just from memory I can tell You that Jerome Mathis (who is poised to emerge as one of the games most exciting returners) got hurt this year and Darren Sproles (who already is one of the best) got hurt last year. And who can forget what happened to Jason Sehorn a few years back.
by kaisertown on Apr 7, 2008 11:27 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Fair enough.
by jj24 on Apr 7, 2008 3:12 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Mcgee's 07 return numbers
by VeroBeachBillsFan on Apr 6, 2008 10:22 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Glad you're here!
You probably have part of the story right about McGee's numbers being down. I think that the injury situation, coupled with opponents' game plans, certainly had a lot to do with McGee's drop in numbers. But to completely discount the fact that McGee may have been winded from time to time is probably a mistake.
Again... McGee can, and will, keep returning kicks. But now is a good time to start easing him out of that role with a talented young returner. It helps us everywhere, and most importantly, it helps McGee.
by Brian Galliford on Apr 6, 2008 11:02 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Terrence plays hard
by Daz28 on Apr 6, 2008 11:00 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I agree with Brian
McGee simply isn't the elite returner he was a few seasons ago. His 24 yards per return were pretty average. He scored 1 of the 25 KR TDs last season. 19 different players found the end zone on KRs last year. It wouldn't really hurt our team to take 25 returns away from McGee next season.
by kaisertown on Apr 6, 2008 11:13 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Yeah but that one return TD was a DOOZIE
by Lance in Germany on Apr 7, 2008 3:58 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
haha
McGee is still an above average KR. Maybe even in the top 10 KRs. Guys like Darren Sproles, Josh Cribbs, Leon Washington and Maurice Jones-Drew have clearly seperated themselves in my mind. I also suspect younger players like Jerious Norwood, Yamon Figurs, Ted Ginn, Jerome Mathis and Aundrae Allsion will emerge as better returners in the next few years as well. McGee is part of a group of effective, but not special rturners like Andre Davis, Rock Cartwright, Aveion Cason, Ellis Hobbs and Dante Hall.
I guess my point is: there are lots of good returners out there. Ours shouldn't be our most experienced defensive back.
by kaisertown on Apr 7, 2008 11:21 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Glad to be a commenter!
by VeroBeachBillsFan on Apr 6, 2008 11:16 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
offense
by The Buffalonian on Apr 6, 2008 2:58 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Freddie
by The Buffalonian on Apr 6, 2008 5:07 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Burton's My Guy
Another guy to keep an eye on is Kenneth Moore from Wake Forest. He's very versatile, as he played both RB and WR at the college level. He could be worth taking a late-round flier on.
by BBFan4Life on Apr 7, 2008 7:51 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Thank You
by Kurupt on Apr 8, 2008 4:54 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 
























