clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Buffalo Bills 2010s All-Decade team

Avengers assemble!

It was a long process to get to this point, but we’ve reached the end of our journey. The All-Decade Buffalo Bills team of the 2010s is fully assembled. Over the past two months, we looked at the best players to don a Bills uniform during that time, and you picked the stars for this group.

Some players played nearly the entire decade with the Bills, and some only appeared for a couple seasons. Some players were truly outstanding in the NFL, and some happened to be the best of a weak set of choices. The full team list, and some notes about the process, are included below. As always, discuss your thoughts in the comments!

Buffalo Bills 2010s All-Decade team

Position Player Voting % Years w/ Bills
Position Player Voting % Years w/ Bills
Quarterback Josh Allen 40% 2018-2019
Running back Fred Jackson 70% 2010-2014
Wide receiver 1 Stevie Johnson 82% 2010-2013
Wide receiver 2 Robert Woods 48% 2013-2016
Tight end Scott Chandler 83% 2010-2014
Offensive flex LeSean McCoy 90% 2015-2018
Left tackle Cordy Glenn 71% 2012-2017
Left guard Richie Incognito 66% 2015-2017
Center Eric Wood 97% 2010-2017
Right guard Kraig Urbik 42% 2010-2015
Right tackle Erik Pears 45% 2010-2014
Edge rusher 1 Jerry Hughes 48% 2013-2019
Defensive lineman 1 Kyle Williams 99% 2010-2018
Defensive lineman 2 Marcell Dareus 83% 2011-2017
Edge rusher 2 Mario Williams 48% 2012-2015
Linebacker 1 Tremaine Edmunds 50% 2018-2019
Linebacker 2 Lorenzo Alexander 46% 2016-2019
Cornerback 1 Tre'Davious White 82% 2017-2019
Cornerback 2 Stephon Gilmore 84% 2012-2016
Safety 1 Jairus Byrd 41% 2010-2013
Safety 2 Micah Hyde 47% 2017-2019
Defensive flex Jordan Poyer 71% 2017-2019
Kicker Stephen Hauschka 40% 2017-2019
Punter Brian Moorman 82% 2010-2013
Kick returner C.J. Spiller 51% 2010-2014
Punt returner Leodis McKelvin 81% 2010-2015
Head coach Sean McDermott 96% 2017-2019
Season of the decade 2019 Buffalo Bills 78% 2019
Player of the decade Kyle Williams 77% 2010-2018


  • By far the closest vote was at edge rusher. Jerry Hughes beat Mario Williams by a nose, with 546 votes to 544. With the two combining for 97% of the overall vote, both players made the team.
  • Kyle Williams claimed the largest share of his vote with a whopping 99%. The only one in the same stratosphere was Eric Wood, who had 97% in his poll.
  • The players with the smallest voting slice were Josh Allen and Stephen Hauschka, both with 40%. In Allen’s poll, Ryan Fitzpatrick had 31% of the vote and Tyrod Taylor 29%. With Hauschka, Rian Lindell claimed 31% and Dan Carpenter 29%.
  • The defense features eight players who made a Pro Bowl while with the Bills, and three who were chosen as First-Team All-Pros. By comparison, the only Pro Bowl selections on offense were LeSean McCoy, Richie Incognito, and Eric Wood. No All-Pros to be found there!
  • Looking for the 2000’s All-Decade poll? You can find it here.